Rating: 
Summary: Technically a better product than Tivo
Review: I purchased this unit about 3 months ago, with the full realization that you pay by the month or a lifetime subscription. I hope that this fiasco people are dealing with this month is resolved happily. If this gets ReplayTV in trouble with the marketplace, that would be a shame.ReplayTV is simply a superior product than Tivo. Don't just look here, look at newsgroups and other bulletin boards. - better video quality
- unlimited buffer time (limited to disk space, not Tivo's arbitrary 15 minutes"
- Automatic Commercial skip (automatic, not just a 30-sec skip.) This feature works GREAT. However, only the 5040 has it, later models do not. REASON ENOUGH to choose ReplayTV 5040 over Tivo.
- Easily upgradeable drive space. See http://replaytv.us
- Network to your home LAN. Download files to your PC for editing and DVD burning. The BIGGEST reason I bought this and not Tivo. I have not had ANY software problems with this system. My wife easily programs it. Only improvement I can think of is recording two shows at once, which only DirecTivo can do, I believe. Don't be scared off by the misunderstanding/marketing goof by ReplayTV this month. I'd hate to see this product lose out to Tivo in the long run.
Rating: 
Summary: ReplayTV RTV5504
Review: I purchased two Replay TV RTV5504 recorders because they were LAN ready and I have regretted it since. With a lot of hassle and time on hold (they did away with there 800 number), I've managed to get my unit replaced 5 TIMES. My first unit failed in about two weeks, three of the replacements they sent did not work right out of the box, two of them worked for about a week. Based solely on my personal experience I recommend that one NEVER BUY FROM REPLAYTV.
Rating:
Summary: Totally Changes TV Viewing Habits
Review: I travel a lot, and the ReplayTV allows me to catch a lot of shows I would otherwise miss. The fact that I can specify shows to record via a web-based interface (my.replaytv.com) lets me come home to shows I neglected to specify before I left.
Problems with my cable modem router (MAC address filtering) caused a glitch in the initial setup of the unit, but once that was resolved everything worked as expected. The unit is so easy to use that the manual is almost unnecessary.
Finally, the ability to archive shows to my PC without hacking the unit is a tremendous plus. I'm very pleased . . . In fact, I'm ordering another for my in-laws!
Rating:
Summary: Never watch commercials again
Review: I've had my ReplayTV for over a year so I think I can give you a good review of it. When I told my wife I wanted to get one she thought it was just another toy but once she saw everything it could do she was hooked. I don't watch a lot of TV but for the shows I like I just record them on the Replay and watch them whenever I have time. My unit will automatically skip 95% of the commercials and for the few that it misses you just hit the 30 second skip button and it jumps right through them. One of the features that I think is the greatest and I didn't see it mentioned much is the fact that if you hook it up to your home network you can get on your PC and go to a website called www.poopli.com and surf through all the shows that other ReplayTV users have shared on their ReplayTV's and when you find a show that maybe you forgot to record or just looks interesting you can request them to send it to your ReplayTV. Then the next time you turn on your ReplayTV you'll see a message that someone is sending you a show and you just have to accept it for the transfer to begin. I know Tivo users only dream about a feature like this one. It's great when I do watch live TV that I can pause and rewind shows for those times when I get a phone call or anything and I don't want to miss anything. When you take a one hour show and strip out the commercials it ends up only being about 40 minutes which is great when you just don't have a lot of time to sit around and watch boring commercials. You can connect your VCR to the ReplayTV and transfer all your tapes to the ReplayTV and then copy them from the ReplayTV to your PC and edit them or just burn them to a DVD so your home movies will last forever in digital format. The 40 hour model is pretty cheap and you can always upgrade the hard drive later or just move the shows to your PC to save space on the ReplayTV. As long as you have your PC turned on and the software running you can play the recorded shows on your PC right to your TV by selecting your PC from the onscreen menu on the ReplayTV. My wife says this is the best toy I ever bought.
Rating: 
Summary: Life changing concept, not ready for prime time
Review: I've had my ReplayTV for two months. The concept is fantastic, and indeed, my TV experience has improved a lot because I'm watching things when I want to and have discovered a litany of great biographies and discovery channel shows. There are some neat features and some frustrating aspects (like the remote, the noise). If I were to do this again, I would seriously look at newer the TiVo products. What's cool:
The ReplayTV unit has built in USB and Ethernet ports. I just connected it to my home LAN and it worked from the onset.
Lots of space inside for a second drive, and it's pretty easy to swap the 40Gb with a 200Gb, thus increasing programming time by 4x. I'll deny any knowledge of having 67 high quality proogramming hours until my warranty expires. :0)
"Zones" guide separates programs up into 12 major categories, over 100 sub-genres. You can set up recording of "zones" (e.g., twisted cynical comedies) or programs. There's basic queue management to ensure your child's animated cartoons don't bump all of the Simpsons episodes (and vice versa).
ReplayTV unit supports multiple inputs, including recording of DVD and VCR content. One side effect is all programming is buffered, thus playing your DVD through the ReplayTV (which I do only because my TV is limited on its inputs) is buffered. On the other hand, this allows me to quickly jog back for a scene. What's disappointing:
The remote has a small cone of reception. What this means is you have to be directly in front of the ReplayTV unit, aiming the remote at the center, for it to register. This makes the remote frustrating.
The commercial skip option is no longer available. ReplayTV caved into pressure. Quick skip works fine for the first two tries, but if you have a block of 3 minutes, it can get confused, especially with the finicky remote (see above).
It's noisy. The hard drive runs *all the time*, even when the unit isn't being used. Since it's in a TV cabinet, I can close the door to filter out the sound. Ideally, it should spin down when not being used.
Support has been frustrating -- I'm able to get a human relatively easily, but each time I have to re-explain my problem with the unit not downloading its software update. The analyst gets stumped, says I should get a call back. This has repeated a few times. Twice, I've been instructed to factory reset the device, losing all of my settings. Features I haven't used:
Multi-unit -- the ReplayTV supports sharing programs among networked units. This sounds pretty cool, though I only have one TV set.
Photographs -- Some of the original disk partition can be allocated to storing digital photos. This isn't particularly useful to me since I have my own website, but maybe for a quick TV-based display, this would be fun.
Rating:
Summary: Change the way you watch television, forever!
Review: It's entirely possible that you're considering the ReplayTV unit simply as a VCR replacement, something to record "the game" when you're gone without the hassle of tapes. As you discover the Replay's incredible functionality, you soon find yourself watching everything from your Replay unit, as every show is available whenever you want it, without the hassle of commercials.
Essentially, the Replay can smartly record whatever show you want, whenever you want it. Every episode of the Simpsons can be recorded whenever it appears at whatever time you want it with two button presses. No longer do you have to trudge through channels, looking for something good, only to realize the episode is a repeat. You set the Replay to record only your most favorite shows, you come home and watch the Replay when you normally watch television, and bammo, you see only your favorite episodes, sans commericals. It's a miracle.
Two main questions people ask: "Tivo vs. Replay" and "What size is best for me. Tivo and Replay are nearly identical. Both let you record shows smartly, both let you pause live TV and fast forward. I prefer the replay because it has a less fluffy interface that gets the job done. Additionally, the Replay remote sports a handy "30 second skip" button in addition to the fast forward buttons, allowing you to conveniently jump through a commerical at a time, as opposed to the Tivo method, fast forwarding through the commericals. (The difference is like skipping over pebbles or running through a lake) This model (along with the other Replay units) feature a "Segment-advance" option, a single click will skip ALL of the commercials between your show. Tivo will record shows similiar to the ones you watch, Replay does not. (Something fluffy I didn't need)
As for size? 40 hours may seem like a lot now, but it's really not. My advice is to buy the 40 hour unit, and then upgrade later to a larger hard drive. Upgrading is a simple process, get any standard ATA hard drive, unplug the Replay drive, plug both into a computer and transfer the data using a free utility, plug the new drive into the Replay and it's all good. (It's much cheaper this way)
Rating:
Summary: So Far.... It's Awesome!
Review: Ok here is a review from a guy that has had both Tivo and ReplayTV units. I have had my ReplayTV 5040 for about a month now and am loving it. Now here comes my two cents... I looked over what everyone else had written before me and I understand their concerns. First off, there is no excuse for any unit to break down that is less than a year old. This is something that always upsets me no matter what the electronic device but it does happen. I have had 3 different Tivo's breakdown on me. One with in the first month I got it. The next one about two years later and my last one just broke down about 2 months ago and that's kind of what prompted me to get the ReplayTV unit. Don't get me wrong, I love Tivo but there is so much more you can do with the ReplayTV. And remember you need to buy an extended service contract for this high priced electronic devices just incase something like this happens! Secondly, everyone must understand that several months back ReplayTV changed their pricing. When the units cost $400, they included the service. But they changed that and the individual stores that carried the units were to clearly mark and explain that the new pricing does not include the service. But many retailers did not do this and the consumers blamed ReplayTV and not the electronic stores they purchased the unit from. I remember the day that the price went down, I was going to buy three of them but then I realized what had happened. The Circuit City store I went to had a notice next to the Replays that clearly stated that with the new price point the service was no longer included. So make sure you are upset with the right people here guys!!! Ok so what is it that I like about the ReplayTV??? I love the fact that there are so many 3rd party programs (or hacks) out there that let you manipulate your unit and do so much more with it. Basically, I have it connected to my home network through my router and am running a program called DVArchive that not only allows me to control my ReplayTV but also to watch shows on it from my computer, transfer shows from my unit to my computer and archive them(unlimited storage space), watch archived shows on my computer from my ReplayTV, network and watch shows to and from other ReplayTV's in my house, trade shows over the internet with other ReplayTV owners(5xxx units only but there are hacks around this), very easily edit out commercials and record the shows onto DVD using your computer and all this costs nothing extra!!! Tivo is a great product for the person that wants an easy to use "mac" like interface. Tivo does have a home networking option but it costs an extra $99 and $49 for each additional unit you hook up. But you currently can not take shows off your Tivo and send them to you computer. Replay includes all these features for free. If you have never owned a PVR once you do it will change the way you watch television- you'll want one for every TV in the house! And I have only discovered the tip of the iceberg when it comes to all the things I can do with my ReplayTV. I think the thing I am going to like the most is putting all my favorite shows on DVD. PS- does anyone want to buy a slightly used Tivo??? lol
Rating:
Summary: technical support is torture...
Review: Our Replay failed after 6 months. We paid 1-way shipping for a non-functional replacement with beta software installed in it. After 6 hour long calls to different offshore "technicians", leading us through painful and sometimes silly reconfigurations of cable modem, router, and Replay (which left the rest of the LAN nonfunctional), we were told "we understand there's a problem with the unit, we'll email you what to do". And like two previous promises to have a technical expert phone us, no thing followed. Please buy something else -- these folks don't deserve your money.
Rating:
Summary: Beats the competition, bar none!
Review: Rarely do I say that one product is superior to another. ReplayTV is by far the best DVR that's available in the market.
When deciding to purchase this, I read the reviews, the comparison charts, the pros and cons. I eventually bought the ReplayTV because it had many of the extras as standard that would have cost an additional $50+ if I bought a Tivo.
The on-board Ethernet port was the deciding factor for me. Having only one television in my apartment, I found it important to be able to view shows in my own room on my computer. The ethernet port allows for it to be hooked up onto your internal network. With the use of software, not only can I download and stream shows onto my computer, but I can also ARCHIVE shows on my computer's hard drive, and then stream them BACK to the replayTV! This is great for Simpsons fans, or whatever, because you can play shows you haven't watched for weeks!
This feature allows for virtually unlimited storage. You can use the software to download and delete shows off your ReplayTV every night. No need to open the DVR and void your warrenty! Simply copy the shows over, and have space to record more shows.
Another reason I went with the ReplayTV was that I did not want my DVR to record things I don't want to watch. Personally, I don't want a machine telling me what I might like or might not like. It may be right and it may be accurate, but please, let me be the judge. I like the control that replayTV offers.
Also, this model comes progressive output, which is a must-have for HDTVs.
Finally, price. Tivo has become a household brand. They are even losing their brand-name like "Kleenex" and "Google". When people talk about any DVR, it usually comes out as "Tivo". Brand-name has a cost, and it is definately not worth it. Spend far less with a ReplayTV. With the mail-in rebate, it's even cheaper.
Subscription price is the same, no matter who you go with.
Watch TV, on your terms! Buy the ReplayTV!
Rating:
Summary: Better than Tivo, but not as good as previous ReplayTVs
Review: ReplayTV is great and has features that Tivo does not. But be careful -- many of the reviews refer to Commercial Advance (automatically skipping commercials) and Internet Video Sharing (ability to sent recorded programs to others via the internet) which are not available on current the 55XX series (5504, 5508, etc.). These features, and great features they are, are only available on the otherwise identical 50XX series units (5040, 5080, etc.). Commercial Advance and Internet Video Sharing are also available on the 45XX series units (4504, 4508, etc.).
|
