Home :: DVD :: Television :: Star Trek  

A&E Home Video
BBC
Classic TV
Discovery Channel
Fox TV
General
HBO
History Channel
Miniseries
MTV
National Geographic
Nickelodeon
PBS
Star Trek

TV Series
WGBH Boston
Star Wars vs. Star Trek

Star Wars vs. Star Trek

List Price: $9.98
Your Price: $9.98
Product Info Reviews

<< 1 2 >>

Rating: 3 stars
Summary: Unbiased
Review: These reviews all seem to ahve a slant... A stark (and mostly raving) slant. One bashes Star Wars, the next bashes Star Trek... Why can't the geeks just get along? I, being the ubergeek I have found myself to have become, am a fan of both. They both have very strong and weak points. I've gleaned that this DVD, which I am reviewing (but have not actually seen... sorry) takes equal opportune punches at both franchises. If you are a fan of either, and have a single humorous bone in your body, it is reasonable to think that you may enjoy the jabs. If you take them as personal insults, you have deep-rooted problems that I couldn't even begin to heal in this forum. May the force live long and prosper (That pun went over the top... I now have to cleanse myself)

Rating: 1 stars
Summary: No VS.
Review: This DVD does not talk about STAR TREK, & star wars, fighting with each other, Because they don't, The VS. is a dumb idea,

These 2 Sci-Fi's were made for people to enjoy, If you watch this DVD through, you will not see anything about VS. It is just a plain documentary talking abouy STAR TREK, & star wars, They are not trying to make you like one over the other, There is an equal amout of insults for both franchises,
star wars actually deserves all the insults you can stuff into it, however STAR TREK does not deserve any of the insults that were in this documentary,
STAR TREK needs to be complimented for it's brilliance & how NO OTHER Sci-Fi's in the world have even come close to being better, (with the exeption of the Matrix, "maybe")

& star wars needs to be hit over the head for it's stupidness & how most other Sci-Fi's are better, If you've seen every Sci-Fi in the world, before 1977, you can probly put together the ENTIRE star wars SERIES with just the clips from the previous Sci-Fi's,

If this DVD was really supposed to be a battle between the 2 Sci-Fi's, They should probly note, that most star wars Fan Sites on the Web, nearly always make fun of STAR TREK, & STAR TREK fan sites, never make fun of star wars, (strange!!!)
It's funny how alot of people think star wars is better than STAR TREK, & then when they start comparing them to other Sci-Fi's,
star wars is always compared to the Bad Sci-Fi's & STAR TREK is always compared to the Good Sci-Fi's, Like

star wars compare it to Starship Troopers & Battlestar Galactica,
(2 really, really bad Sci-Fi's)

STAR TREK, compare it to the Aliens movies, & the Matrix
(2 really, really Good Sci-Fi's)

How do people think STAR TREK is so bad when people think they're so simmilar to the ones on the list above,

How do people think star wars is so good when people think they're so simmilar to the ones on the list above,

But me, I think STAR TREK will always be better than star wars,
But why compare them with each other, They have nothing in common,

Rating: 4 stars
Summary: This is Great.
Review: This is what many Star Wars and Star Trek fans have always anticipated to see. Two of the greatest Science Fiction stories of all time. It's been argued of who is better or worse, this will be cool. Great collectible for ST and Sw fans even though it's only ten bucks.

Rating: 1 stars
Summary: I would a "real" documentry made on this instead,
Review: This very poorly produced film only makes me want to see a "real" documentry made, co-produced by Paramount and 20th Century Fox on the possitive effects that these two space sagas have had for their fans and for pop culture in general. That would be better and more fitting, then this tabloid trash film.

Rating: 1 stars
Summary: I would a "real" documentry made on this instead,
Review: This very poorly produced film only makes me want to see a "real" documentry made, co-produced by Paramount and 20th Century Fox on the possitive effects that these two space sagas have had for their fans and for pop culture in general. That would be better and more fitting, then this tabloid trash film.


<< 1 2 >>

© 2004, ReviewFocus or its affiliates