Home :: Communications :: Cell Phones  

Accessories
Audiovox
Handspring
Kyocera (Qualcomm)
LGIC
Motorola
Nokia
Panasonic
Samsung
Sanyo
Sony Ericsson
Motorola i58srg Gray Phone (Nextel)

Motorola i58srg Gray Phone (Nextel)

List Price: $169.99
Your Price: $149.99
Product Info Reviews

<< 1 >>

Rating: 4 stars
Summary: Works Well
Review: I have had this phone for about a year now. My husband is very careless with his phones (always dropping them, leaving them in the wrong places) and so far, this phone has lasted with him. The only reason I gave it a 4 is the phone is bulky and not very attractive. Also it does not work in some basements and areas at my school.

Rating: 4 stars
Summary: Works Well
Review: I have had this phone for about a year now. My husband is very careless with his phones (always dropping them, leaving them in the wrong places) and so far, this phone has lasted with him. The only reason I gave it a 4 is the phone is bulky and not very attractive. Also it does not work in some basements and areas at my school.

Rating: 3 stars
Summary: Yin & Yang: Wake up Motorola!
Review: The Good: Finally, somebody else realizes the benefit of a rubber coating and its durability. Panasonic's Duramax was my favorite, but it's discontinued. I'm surprised no one makes rubber snap on covers for all the phones. Drop the phone, chances are good it won't break. Moisture resistant (not clothes washer resistant, neither was my Duramax). Scratches nil. A good work phone for tough environments.

The built in speaker phone is great. I especially like the adjustable font size, which sold me on this phone. Color is prettier, but what good is it if I can't see the text? The bland screen makes up for appearance with function...good contrast for seeing even in direct sunlight.

The Not So Good: The speed dial numbers are set automatically and cannot be user defined without erasing the entire entry and info for the person/number auto-assigned to that specific speed dial number. You assign the speed dial number, and it erases whatever occupied it, completely. The logic of this completely evades me. All data for the deleted entry has to be re-entered. Also, every number gets assigned a speed dial number. No choice.

The larger extended life battery was standard with my phone. The design doubles the thickness of the phone. Each battery size requires a different battery cover, most of which are not rubber coated, and sold separately from each battery. Drop the phone on the backside with these covers, it will break. If you have several batteries, plan on having to keep track of the appropriate cover that goes with it. More things to lose.

So far I cannot get the long life battery to last 1 day, with minimal use. The advertised rated talk time is nowhere near reality. I've bought a smaller battery and smaller cover and testing the standby and talk times. May be the long life battery I received is almost DOA.

The battery can be overcharged and damaged, and the charger provided does not detect this and shut off. Aftermarket chargers claim they protect the battery from this.

Bottom Line: You want a very basic durable working person's phone, this is a good one. You want pretty and color and small with lots of ring tones and gizmos, this is not.

Lots of decent accessories available. Car charger is a must.

Wish Motorola would fix the speed dial software, such a basic thing on most all phones. The battery/cover designs are ridiculous. Should be one battery cover for all.


<< 1 >>

© 2004, ReviewFocus or its affiliates