<< 1 >>
Rating: 
Summary: This is THE book to get for beginning in Oriental Painting
Review: As a relative newcomer myself to Chinese Oriental Painting, I drifted through a LOT of titles - until I found this one. Not even the shops in San Francisco's Chinatown have this book. It is thoroughly laid out, with lots of lovely color pics and every section has a practical lesson to follow and learn from. In depth discussion of tools and equipment options are discussed, and different techniques and applications are displayed and explained in just the right amount of detail. This is also a hardback book, and, in my opinion, represents real value for money. I shall lovingly keep this book forever as a great momento of my beginning with this medium, a fine and wonderful work. I can't recommend this book highly enough - it's great.
Rating: 
Summary: A real disappointment
Review: I bought this book for help in working with color, having already done some ink work with the "four gentlemen." I found it very poor in practical information, and can't imagine how a beginner could learn anything from it. There is very little clear information on even basic brush strokes or on loading the brush, much less on other techniques for color work. Moreover, there is extensive emphasis on the composition aspects of calligraphy and the use of seals, which is most unhelpful for someone who does not know Chinese. The examples include the cursive and seal form of the characters; any attempt to imitate these would make a fool out of anyone who did not know Chinese calligraphy. The positive aspect of the book were the prints of the authors' work. Some of these were interesting and quite lovely. Unfortunately, I did not want a portfolio; I wanted a "how to" guide. The only useful alternatives I have found at this point are the two publications by Ning Yeh, which you can order from OAS. I had been hoping for another instructor's point of view. I would say that the authors of Oriental Painting Course are fine artists, but very poor instructors.
Rating:
Summary: A real disappointment
Review: I bought this book for help in working with color, having already done some ink work with the "four gentlemen." I found it very poor in practical information, and can't imagine how a beginner could learn anything from it. There is very little clear information on even basic brush strokes or on loading the brush, much less on other techniques for color work. Moreover, there is extensive emphasis on the composition aspects of calligraphy and the use of seals, which is most unhelpful for someone who does not know Chinese. The examples include the cursive and seal form of the characters; any attempt to imitate these would make a fool out of anyone who did not know Chinese calligraphy. The positive aspect of the book were the prints of the authors' work. Some of these were interesting and quite lovely. Unfortunately, I did not want a portfolio; I wanted a "how to" guide. The only useful alternatives I have found at this point are the two publications by Ning Yeh, which you can order from OAS. I had been hoping for another instructor's point of view. I would say that the authors of Oriental Painting Course are fine artists, but very poor instructors.
Rating:
Summary: A real disappointment
Review: If I had to recommend one oriental painting book, this would be it. It includes the most information and the clearest explanations. It is also in full-color and has many beautiful illustrations throughout. First, the book covers materials including how to choose papers, brushes, and inks. I found the photos of each brush to be very helpful. It then teaches you to how to hold the brush correctly & make basic Asian characters. There are wonderful step-by-step demonstrations on painting bamboo, orchids, wisteria, chysanthemums, plum blossoms & various animals. Also covered are various landscape elements, water types, buildings, & figures. The book also covers qi, color, composition, perspective, mounting your artwork and using seals. Some historical information and a glossary in the back are great bonuses.
Rating:
Summary: Best oriental paiting book, beautiful illustrations
Review: If I had to recommend one oriental painting book, this would be it. It includes the most information and the clearest explanations. It is also in full-color and has many beautiful illustrations throughout. First, the book covers materials including how to choose papers, brushes, and inks. I found the photos of each brush to be very helpful. It then teaches you to how to hold the brush correctly & make basic Asian characters. There are wonderful step-by-step demonstrations on painting bamboo, orchids, wisteria, chysanthemums, plum blossoms & various animals. Also covered are various landscape elements, water types, buildings, & figures. The book also covers qi, color, composition, perspective, mounting your artwork and using seals. Some historical information and a glossary in the back are great bonuses.
Rating: 
Summary: a good beginner's book on free brush painting
Review: This book could be a good beginner's text for self-teaching on traditional East Asian brush painting popular in China, Korea, and Japan. This book comprises 22 lessons, starting from calligraphy of Chinese characters to a complete landscape with people and animals, with reasonable instructions and beautiful paintings as examples. However, this book emphasizes "xieyi" (free brush painting) rather than "gongbi" (fine brush painting). To those who prefer "gongbi" (as I do), it is somewhat disappointing.
Rating:
Summary: a good beginner's book on free brush painting
Review: This book could be a good beginner's text for self-teaching on traditional East Asian brush painting popular in China, Korea, and Japan. This book comprises 22 lessons, starting from calligraphy of Chinese characters to a complete landscape with people and animals, with reasonable instructions and beautiful paintings as examples. However, this book emphasizes "xieyi" (free brush painting) rather than "gongbi" (fine brush painting). To those who prefer "gongbi" (as I do), it is somewhat disappointing.
Rating:
Summary: A+++
Review: Wonderful book with explanations of origin and culture - great addition to your art book library - excellent read and techniques!
<< 1 >>
| 
