Rating: 
Summary: the best there is.
Review: This is the first book in the trilogy; and even as a standalone it's a masterpiece, if any author is to be viewed as a master; as they talk about Mozart, etc. Tolkien is to be for his lifework. The fellowship of the ring is from the beginning to the end a linguistic maze; those who have troubles with beautiful; almost poetic, language; will not appreciate this, but set aside that; and look only at the contains of this work, and you'll realize what a brilliant mind Tolkien had, noticeably is that he took much inspiration from Nordic, Preussic and Greek mythology; which adds to the atmosphere and feeling of this book, everything feels real; authentic, as if it was written in experience, I've read David Eddings, I've read Elizabeth Moon, but they are just mere pale copies compared to J.R.R Tolkien, (not saying they're bad though, just emphasizing on how great Tolkien is). This is a book that really is best experienced alone, in a dark room, with some soft moody music and just enough light to read, be terrified, be amazed, be astounded.To those who have yet to read this, and these books: I am in envy, the first experience of them is incredible, just put a little effort into it, and you will be rewarded times 1000.
Rating: 
Summary: I'll be nice...
Review: Now maybe because it was too long or I'm not into all this fairy tale kinda stories but I didn't enjoy this book one bit. It was slow and uninteresting in many parts. I had English Honors for Sophmore year...it was the worst experience I've ever had with a book. It had to drag myself to read that book. I think the book is GREAT for fires...right shmi?!? Sorry all you people who did like it. But maybe cause you read the sequels. I think Ill pass. I have nighmares everytime I see that book in the bookstore. MAKE IT STOOOP!
Rating:
Summary: Book of this century...and all centuries
Review: The Lord of the Rings...there are precious few in the English-speaking world who have not heard of it spoken in some context of grandeuer, of respect, of hype. To summarise, it DELIVERS. The Fellowship of the Rings may be long and complex, but is the epitome of all that is simple literature. JRR Tolkein uses his remarkable poetic and philological talents to guide us through an entirely distinct universe, and in the fashion of Classical, Norse and Irish legend and mythology envigorates the mind with each twist and turn in the basic struggle against good and evil. With the literary skill of a master seanachaí, he relates the tales of a new quasi-mythology...this book isn't fantasy, to an open-minded reader it is a new level of reality; we may learn as much from the thematic structure of the Lord of the Rings than we do from the innards of a history book. No other novel has delved as deeply into the mind of the author, and none have manifested these ideas as well to the reader. The Fellowship may seem boring to the short attention-span casual reader, but with a little perseverance the rewards are amazing. An leabhair milaois...The book of the millennium.
Rating:
Summary: I've seen both worlds
Review: Look, I have heard both sides of the LOTR debate: the Epical adventure + the boring drag. In fact, I have been to both sides. I read the Lord Of The QRings for the first time when I was seven. I loved it. Sure, it took me a month, and sure most of it went over my head. But I loved it (although I hated the actual reading part. Now I have read it sixteen more times, and I can safely say I know where everyone is coming from. Book one, The Fellowship of the Ring, is fantastic in it's own way, but it does become repeditive and a little tedious. It is brilliant, but hard to get into and really live. The second book WITHIN the first novel is amazing. This is where Tolkien starts his action. At first I struggled through the first book, but now I breeze through, knowing there is great stuff ahead. Book two and three are brilliant, if a bit naive and neat for my taste. Tolkien is the origional and the best EVER FANTASY WRITER!!! I can say this confidently as having read most popular fantasy series' and his is the most origional and epical I have ever seen.
Rating:
Summary: This book is among the best I have ever read...
Review: This book is the opening chapter of the epic "Lord of the Rings Trilogy", the best series of books (I believe) ever written. This book sets the foundation more solidly than "The Hobbit" does and begins to unveil Tolkein's modern myth. This book is only rivaled by the other books in the Trilogy and by "The Silmarilion" which was also written by Tolikein.
Rating: 
Summary: It was boring then interesting....but mostly boring....
Review: What's to say, tolkien's a very good author in his own way. You don't feel his character's though, you don't care about them much. 500 pages seems really really long in this books. You know how in some books you hardly noticed that you've read 100 pages. Not so here, I swear I looked at the page numbers all of the time and got nowhere. I read the first 200 pages (which were really boring) then got to the interesting part. Unfortunatly the report on it was due the next day so all day I spent reading it page by page until it was finished. Moria was good Rivendell and Elf Land were dragged out quite alot. I give it three because it's very high quality writing. Structurally sound. I just failed to pick it up and soar...if you get my meaning. Don't get me wrong though, the hobbit and the rest of the trilogy are really good.
Rating:
Summary: When does it STOP GETTING BORING??????
Review: okay when i was 12 i read the hobbit and luved it. Then i decided to pick up Fellowship and after about 5 chapters of nothing happening i gave up...2 yrs passed and i decided to try again. Fisrt i got the hobbit again (and enjoyed it again!)then i started Fellowship again, it got boring again but i made myself read on....now i'm on the 150pg and there's been almost NO action and almost NOTHING important happening so i'm gonna give up again...the only reason i give it 3 starz is cuz i hear the next 2 books r real good..but i can't make myslef read the rest of Fellowship...i fall asleep!
Rating:
Summary: BEST FANTASY EVER WRITTEN
Review: There is no comparison. No other fantasy saga has anywhere near the level of depth and feeling. And that's all anyone can say. You must, I assure you, read this before you die. It is, I say without irony, another world.
Rating: 
Summary: sluggish and overlong
Review: Has some engaging bits in it, but really only for real fantasy die-hards
Rating:
Summary: A story that you would die to be a part of
Review: The Lord of the Rings is the only book you can read over and over again. You can either take it from the beginning, or simply jump to the chapters and scenes that you enjoy the most. It is a book that at its ending it leaves you with a somewhat bitter mood, with the desire to follow those who depart to the West, to learn even more about stories of Middle Earth. Indeed when it is finished you wish you could just forget all about it and read it again as for the first time. Certainly those who have felt what I have for this book can understand what I am talking about. For everybody else, I hope you may be able to read any book which will cause you such feelings.
|
