Rating: 
Summary: Standard W.E.B. Griffin fare
Review: Nothing overly special about this book. Griffin stands true the the schitck of his genre, mainly 1) Deflowered Virgins, 2) Rich Playboys in the military service, and 3) Enlisted men who must become officers by the end of the story. If you can deal with that, its no better or worse than the other books in the series.
However, there are serious problems with continuity in this book. Names and events that took place in prior books and are remembered in this one are so inaccurate, I'm seriously starting to suspect that after Book III or so, these things are being ghostwritten.
Rating: 
Summary: More fantasy than historical fiction
Review: I listened to the audio version, abridged. It was very boring, almost impossible to keep up with the characters, very little action, convoluted plot, ridiculous (by today's standards) love scenes over and over again with too many couples to keep track of. The abridgement may have been part of the problem. I had to finally go and read the dust jacket of the book to understand what the basic plot was: a mission in the Gobi desert by the Marines, to save a group trying to escape from the expected Japanese assault of China, and to erect a meteorology station. I guess you have to understand World War II better than I do to understand why all of this was important to the war effort. Also, it may have disadvantaged me that this is the first Griffin book I have tried, by listening or otherwise. I can see where World War II buffs might get a big kick out of these endless details, constant references to rank, with virtually nothing said about the people's physical appearances, personality traits, et cetera, so that it's really hard to tell how one General or Lieutenant Colonel differs from another, and how they all differ from each other. Well, I know the big names in the book: Roosevelt, Nimitz, MacArthur, "Wild Bill" Donovan....but I would have liked more information on one of these individuals, more focus, more of a personality or psychological study instead of this roughshod back and forth geographical moves, jumping all over the world for brief snapshots of the goings-on of the heroes of this book, womanizers for the most part. Ah jus' don' get it, Cap'n McCoy! (he's the main man, as opposed to the Generals, methinks, at least I got that much). If any of this is autobiographical, Mr. Griffin must have led a very confusing life. OCD? Diximus with feeling.
Rating:
Summary: A Waste of Time
Review: I picked up these books hoping to gain some insight into the actions of the Marine Corps in the Pacific during World War II. What I found instead was a sort of soap opera that rambles on for hundreds of pages without getting around to much actual fighting. For example, The Marines don't even get to Guadalcanal (their first major offensive) until the end of book III, some 1200 pages into the story. Those 1200 intervening pages are mostly conversations (ad nauseam) between stateside Marine Corps officers as they sit around headquarters, or go out on the town chasing skirts.
The small portion of the books that is devoted to actual battles is done in such a cursory fashion that you're left with the impression that the author either finds this aspect of the Marines' mission distasteful, or doesn't understand it well enough to write about it. Mr. Griffin could have deleted about 80% of his material, and would have ended up with better books, albeit still not good ones.If you're the sort of person who likes to watch daytime soap operas, then you may enjoy these books. If, on the other hand, you're interested in military history, the banality of these books will leave you screaming in frustration.
Rating:
Summary: Padded and talky
Review: I'm currently reading this book, almost 200 pages (!) into it, and I wonder: will the story ever get started?
This is talky, repetitive writing -- some brief flashes of insight and humor in overwritten scenes as historical characters walk on-stage, but not enough. The author's research is obvious, not skillfully woven in (to use a cliché), and often relegated to parentheses.
So far, I say, Get started with the story! It's like a military and political soap opera. Maybe things will pick up once, or if, the action begins.
|
