Rating: 
Summary: Not Up To This Author's Standard
Review: Author Kaminsky is able to do everything a writer ought to do for this type of detective story except make the reader give a damn for anyone in it. A wronged young woman steals a cache of stories written by a famous writer and begins to destroy the stories piece by piece as the detective searches for her and for the writings. The novel reads like a local Sarasota travelogue (Sarasota is where author Kaminsky resides) and the story is recounted in the first person by "hero" Lew Fonesca. He tells the story in an unadorned no-frills fashion, simply recounting facts. The unfortunate result of this technique is that we simply don't care who wins, loses, is guilty, or innocent, or WHY! "Folk-siness" only takes an author so far. He/she also has to give you REASONS TO CARE. Kaminsky doesn't.
Rating: 
Summary: Not quite as good as "Vengeance".....
Review: but Stuart Kaminsky succeeds again with Retribution!We're back in Sarasota with Lewis Fonesca, again. Kaminsky succeeds in fleshing out some of the characters he introduced in Vengeance, and gives us some quirky new ones in this tale of revenge. It seems that famous, reclusive author Conrad Lonsberg,
who is hiding from the world in plain sight, in beautiful Sarasota, is the subject of a vendetta. His rich portfolio of unpublished books, the heritage for his grandchildren, has disappeared, taken by the young Adele, a foster teen from Kaminsky's earlier work. Adele is destroying the work, piece by piece, to avenge some unknown issue caused by Lonsberg. Along the way, people associated with Adele keep turning up dead. Kaminsky succeeds in keeping Adele's motivation a secret until the climax of the novel. Once again, the quirky Fonesca is able to win the hearts and minds of those he meets, simply by being himself, even as he struggles with his own sadness. Dr. Horowitz, Flo, Adele, Sally and Ames are all back, and Kaminsky continues to draw them in watercolor while he makes stunning observations about the beauty of the Sarasota region, and contrasts it to the honky-tonk parts of town. In addition, he uses the quirk of defining Lew by detailed descriptions of the food he eats, much as Lawrence Sanders did with his odd heroes and heroines. There is a subplot involving a character called Crazy Marvin, that we could do without, but the moments spent by Lew helping a homeless man called Digger are priceless. Kaminsky continues to have success profiling a very ordinary man
in a very unusual business. Bravo!
Rating:
Summary: Not quite as good as "Vengeance".....
Review: but Stuart Kaminsky succeeds again with Retribution! We're back in Sarasota with Lewis Fonesca, again. Kaminsky succeeds in fleshing out some of the characters he introduced in Vengeance, and gives us some quirky new ones in this tale of revenge. It seems that famous, reclusive author Conrad Lonsberg,
who is hiding from the world in plain sight, in beautiful Sarasota, is the subject of a vendetta. His rich portfolio of unpublished books, the heritage for his grandchildren, has disappeared, taken by the young Adele, a foster teen from Kaminsky's earlier work. Adele is destroying the work, piece by piece, to avenge some unknown issue caused by Lonsberg. Along the way, people associated with Adele keep turning up dead. Kaminsky succeeds in keeping Adele's motivation a secret until the climax of the novel. Once again, the quirky Fonesca is able to win the hearts and minds of those he meets, simply by being himself, even as he struggles with his own sadness. Dr. Horowitz, Flo, Adele, Sally and Ames are all back, and Kaminsky continues to draw them in watercolor while he makes stunning observations about the beauty of the Sarasota region, and contrasts it to the honky-tonk parts of town. In addition, he uses the quirk of defining Lew by detailed descriptions of the food he eats, much as Lawrence Sanders did with his odd heroes and heroines. There is a subplot involving a character called Crazy Marvin, that we could do without, but the moments spent by Lew helping a homeless man called Digger are priceless. Kaminsky continues to have success profiling a very ordinary man
in a very unusual business. Bravo!
Rating:
Summary: Welcome back, Mr. Fonesca
Review: Early this year I was pleasantly surprised when I read VENGEANCE by Stuart Kaminsky. I was expecting a short, quick and probably forgettable novel. Boy, was I mistaken. The characters are very down-to-earth trying to find some happiness with their lives. All the characters have a point of weakness (alcoholism, loneliness, anger, among others) that they are trying to conquer in their lives day by day. The main character in this series is Lew Fonesca, a process server who is now living in Sarasota while trying to escape his former life in Chicago. He is trying to move forward ever since the accidental death of his wife Catherine. Through his work, he meets a lot of people who later become his friends as well as allies. In RETRIBUTION, most of the characters from the previous novel returns including Adele, a runaway who was the main focus in VENGEANCE. In this book a few months have passed. Adele is living a happier life, going to school, and winning prizes in writing competitions. A reclusive author (a la J. D. Salinger) befriends her and tries to help her with her writing. A few months later, Adele runs away from the author's house, stealing all his unpublished works and threatening to destroy every single page slowly. Fonesca is on the case because he is truly concerned about Adele. He cares for her and also has a support network of friends that also cares for Adele. The bad news is that most people of the people Adele encounters during her escapade are winding up dead. Lew is going everything that is necessary to bring Adele back to safety as well as bring more stability to his life. My only complaint about this book is the self-righteousness of Adele's character. She refuses to tell anyone why she is doing what she is doing until the very end. Her behavior was a little extreme and I would have liked to read more about the circumstances that led to her actions. All this is explained in about two pages of text which leaves the reader a bit in the lurch. For everything else, I like the Lew Fonesca series and I intend to continue it as long as I can. I am also going to try to read Kaminsky's other works to see if I feel the same way about his other series characters.
Rating:
Summary: Girl On The Run
Review: Five years ago, Lew Fonesca lost his wife Catherine in a terrible auto accident. The event all but ended his life. Lost and dead inside, he drove to Sarasota, Florida because there was really no other place to go. When the car died in front of a Dairy Queen, he stopped. But he didn't start living again. Instead, he started building himself a cocoon that isolated him from the rest of the world. Trained as an investigator for the state's attorney office in Cook County, Fonesca sets up shop as a process server, establishing just enough money to keep a roof over his head and provide the extravagance of buying videotapes of old movies. Despite his efforts to cut himself off, the world has a way of reaching out to him and dragging him back. Finding people professionally has a tendency to do that, and Ann Horowitz, his counselor, says that by choosing that line of work he's also choosing to find himself-even if he won't admit it. Still smarting from a slap from a Bubbles Dreemer, a woman he had to serve a summons to earlier in the day, Fonesca is approached by Marvin Uliaks, a local handyman that Fonesca know because Marvin cleans the bathroom once a week in the complex where he keeps his office. Marvin hires Fonesca to look for his sister Vera Lynn, who has been missing for over twenty years. She and her husband disappeared after the suspicious death of another young woman all of them knew. Some said that the woman jumped through a window and committed suicide; others insisted that Vera Lynn or her husband threw her out. Marvin doesn't tell Fonesca any of this in the beginning. At the same time, Flo Zink, one of the small list of friends Fonesca has, calls to let him know Adele, a girl that Fonesca rescued only a few short months ago, has disappeared. Prior to vanishing, Adele had been working with Conrad Lonsberg, a reclusive award-winning novelist, on her writing. Flo is currently sixteen-year old Adele's guardian, appointed by the state of Florida. Sally Porovsky, Fonesca's dating acquaintance, is also Adele's caseworker, so Fonesca ends up caught between Flo and Sally, trying to figure out how to get Adele to come back home. Fonesca takes up both trails with Ames McKinney, a seventy-five year old maverick cowboy with a penchant for action instead of dialogue and an arsenal large enough to defend a Third World country. The trail turns bloody from the onset. While Adele remains in hiding and burning the only copies there are of Conrad Lonsberg's unpublished manuscripts, which are potentially worth millions of dollars, someone begins looking for her, leaving a trail of bodies behind. Prolific mystery writer Stuart Kaminsky currently has four mystery series underway and adds new volumes to each. He began his writing career in 1977 with A BULLET FOR A STAR, the first Toby Peters mystery. The Peters mystery series currently has 22 volumes, is set in 1940s Hollywood (Kaminsky was also a film historian and college professor), and always features at least one star of the times that Peters has to help out. His Inspector Porfiry Rostnikov novels are about a Moscow policeman. Abe Lieberman is a solid Jewish detective with a pragmatic streak set in Chicago. He's also written two novels featuring James Garner's signature character, Jim Rockford, from the television show, THE ROCKFORD FILES. Lew Fonesca is a complicated detective. He's clever and he's steady, but he lacks the central core of ambition that is at the heart of so many fictional characters. In the first book, Fonesca comes off as perhaps too distant, but Kaminsky corrects for that by telling an engaging tale filled with pathos and rich characters. The author also moves the tale along at a blistering pace. In RETRIBUTION, Fonesca is slowly moving closer to being a full person again. He still has his depression but says that it beats the anxiety that replaces the depression when the depression goes away, which so many readers in today's hectic world can relate to. The writing is lucid and tight, moving the story along briskly while taking time to establish scene and character. The relationship between Ames and Fonesca is really well done and lends itself to Fonesca's character. Ames is there to provide support in a physical and firepower way, but also to be frank and forthright without waxing philosophical. Ames is a key figure and easy to grasp, and when he solidifies Fonesca's thinking, it only takes a few words. Despite Fonesca's best efforts, his life is growing and the world is drawing him back into it. The mysteries are on the light side, but both are fraught with emotion and a sense of history and family, themes that seem to resonate well within the Lew Fonesca series. Good as the mystery aspects are within the novel, a little more set-up would have been welcome. Adele's motivation came a little too late in the novel, and neither the reader nor Fonesca seemed to have a fair chance at it. Also, although the solution to this mystery was hinted at, the clues weren't solidly in place. Some readers won't like the fact that Fonesca got some of the answers and Kaminsky didn't share them with his audience until he closed the novel. RETRIBUTION is a good read for mystery and private eye readers that like emotional depth and complexity in their tales. And when it comes to sheer reading enjoyment, a confident hand, and a down-home storytelling style, Stuart Kaminsky is money in the bank every time.
Rating:
Summary: Girl On The Run
Review: Five years ago, Lew Fonesca lost his wife Catherine in a terrible auto accident. The event all but ended his life. Lost and dead inside, he drove to Sarasota, Florida because there was really no other place to go. When the car died in front of a Dairy Queen, he stopped. But he didn't start living again. Instead, he started building himself a cocoon that isolated him from the rest of the world. Trained as an investigator for the state's attorney office in Cook County, Fonesca sets up shop as a process server, establishing just enough money to keep a roof over his head and provide the extravagance of buying videotapes of old movies. Despite his efforts to cut himself off, the world has a way of reaching out to him and dragging him back. Finding people professionally has a tendency to do that, and Ann Horowitz, his counselor, says that by choosing that line of work he's also choosing to find himself-even if he won't admit it. Still smarting from a slap from a Bubbles Dreemer, a woman he had to serve a summons to earlier in the day, Fonesca is approached by Marvin Uliaks, a local handyman that Fonesca know because Marvin cleans the bathroom once a week in the complex where he keeps his office. Marvin hires Fonesca to look for his sister Vera Lynn, who has been missing for over twenty years. She and her husband disappeared after the suspicious death of another young woman all of them knew. Some said that the woman jumped through a window and committed suicide; others insisted that Vera Lynn or her husband threw her out. Marvin doesn't tell Fonesca any of this in the beginning. At the same time, Flo Zink, one of the small list of friends Fonesca has, calls to let him know Adele, a girl that Fonesca rescued only a few short months ago, has disappeared. Prior to vanishing, Adele had been working with Conrad Lonsberg, a reclusive award-winning novelist, on her writing. Flo is currently sixteen-year old Adele's guardian, appointed by the state of Florida. Sally Porovsky, Fonesca's dating acquaintance, is also Adele's caseworker, so Fonesca ends up caught between Flo and Sally, trying to figure out how to get Adele to come back home. Fonesca takes up both trails with Ames McKinney, a seventy-five year old maverick cowboy with a penchant for action instead of dialogue and an arsenal large enough to defend a Third World country. The trail turns bloody from the onset. While Adele remains in hiding and burning the only copies there are of Conrad Lonsberg's unpublished manuscripts, which are potentially worth millions of dollars, someone begins looking for her, leaving a trail of bodies behind. Prolific mystery writer Stuart Kaminsky currently has four mystery series underway and adds new volumes to each. He began his writing career in 1977 with A BULLET FOR A STAR, the first Toby Peters mystery. The Peters mystery series currently has 22 volumes, is set in 1940s Hollywood (Kaminsky was also a film historian and college professor), and always features at least one star of the times that Peters has to help out. His Inspector Porfiry Rostnikov novels are about a Moscow policeman. Abe Lieberman is a solid Jewish detective with a pragmatic streak set in Chicago. He's also written two novels featuring James Garner's signature character, Jim Rockford, from the television show, THE ROCKFORD FILES. Lew Fonesca is a complicated detective. He's clever and he's steady, but he lacks the central core of ambition that is at the heart of so many fictional characters. In the first book, Fonesca comes off as perhaps too distant, but Kaminsky corrects for that by telling an engaging tale filled with pathos and rich characters. The author also moves the tale along at a blistering pace. In RETRIBUTION, Fonesca is slowly moving closer to being a full person again. He still has his depression but says that it beats the anxiety that replaces the depression when the depression goes away, which so many readers in today's hectic world can relate to. The writing is lucid and tight, moving the story along briskly while taking time to establish scene and character. The relationship between Ames and Fonesca is really well done and lends itself to Fonesca's character. Ames is there to provide support in a physical and firepower way, but also to be frank and forthright without waxing philosophical. Ames is a key figure and easy to grasp, and when he solidifies Fonesca's thinking, it only takes a few words. Despite Fonesca's best efforts, his life is growing and the world is drawing him back into it. The mysteries are on the light side, but both are fraught with emotion and a sense of history and family, themes that seem to resonate well within the Lew Fonesca series. Good as the mystery aspects are within the novel, a little more set-up would have been welcome. Adele's motivation came a little too late in the novel, and neither the reader nor Fonesca seemed to have a fair chance at it. Also, although the solution to this mystery was hinted at, the clues weren't solidly in place. Some readers won't like the fact that Fonesca got some of the answers and Kaminsky didn't share them with his audience until he closed the novel. RETRIBUTION is a good read for mystery and private eye readers that like emotional depth and complexity in their tales. And when it comes to sheer reading enjoyment, a confident hand, and a down-home storytelling style, Stuart Kaminsky is money in the bank every time.
Rating: 
Summary: Lean writing and a great mystery that will haunt you
Review: Kaminsky's books always get under my skin, even when I pick them up at the worst times - when I'm half-awake, feeling distracted or just not prepared to lose myself in a good book. Even so, I usually can't put down a Kaminsky novel until the very last page.
This time around, Lew Fonseca, a detective who's appeared in other Kaminsky novels, is trying to find out what happened to a young runaway named Adele. She is somehow connected to a very solitary and eccentric bestselling author and the loss of some valuable manuscripts.
The mystery in this one will certainly hold your interest but equally compelling is Kaminsky's style. His books are lean and taut, with no wasted words or "padding" to lessen the drama and suspense...yet somehow he manages to create complex, believable characters and compelling mysteries as well. I'm always amazed at how well he pulls it off, book after book. With books costing as much as they do (the paperback edition of this one set me back 6.99) you might as well spend your money on a book written by a writer who is this good. Then, of course, you're going to want to buy more of his books...but trust me, it'll be worth it.
Rating:
Summary: Well crafted and well written!
Review: Retribution is a classic mystery novel that is well written and well told. The details fit, the questions are answered, and the story moves. Lew Fonesca, a "bumbling competent" unlicensed private investigator, gets his man and affects everyone's life but his own. He is making progress, however, because it is when we help others that we help ourselves. This is an enjoyable book.
Rating:
Summary: Well crafted and well written!
Review: Retribution is a classic mystery novel that is well written and well told. The details fit, the questions are answered, and the story moves. Lew Fonesca, a "bumbling competent" unlicensed private investigator, gets his man and affects everyone's life but his own. He is making progress, however, because it is when we help others that we help ourselves. This is an enjoyable book.
Rating:
Summary: Who cares?
Review: There are certainly redeeming features to this novel (meshing of the past in present in Fonesca, the sense of mystery) but the bottom line is that I just didn't care what happened to the characters. Fonesca is wallowing in old movies (although he seems well read he shows no interest in reading). Ames lives in a bar even though he's capable of much more. I can understand how Adele turned out the way she did but she's still pretty bratty.
The highlight of the novel for me was Fonesca's take on Stephen King: "overpayed and underrated".
It's a shame I didn't enjoy this novel more because Kaminsky is an excellent writer. His whole Rostnikov series is absolutely fabulous - every single one of them. You really empathise with those characters - maybe because they're putting real effort into their lives.
|
