Heart Earth

Rating:
Summary: Surprisingly good...
Review: ...condsidering that I was suffering from metaphor fatigue by the end of the second page.

I suppose it's a matter of taste, but the whole book was "waxing poetic," and I found the style to be a bit tedious. I much prefer a writer who just tells the story and breaks out the occasional metaphor for emphasis. You don't really need one in every single sentence.

Otherwise I enjoyed the book.

Rating:
Summary: A Wondrous Treasure
Review: After reading HEART EARTH for the third time, I find that I am still amazed and touched by Ivan Doig's gift. His words, and the way his phrases flow move me, and I am thankful for the many hours I have spent immersed in Mr. Doig's Montana. Although Heart Earth is basically a tale of discovery (or rediscovery), it is also a tale of hope, love and the eternal connection between a child and a parent, no matter what the circumstances or how far the distance in miles or years. If you've never read anything by this author, do yourself a favor: read every one of his books. Buy them in hardcover, keep them safe, and re-read them again and again. I have a special shelf in my personal library for his books, and I treasure every one of them. Thank you, Mr. Doig, for sharing your gift with me.

Rating:
Summary: A Wondrous Treasure
Review: After reading HEART EARTH for the third time, I find that I am still amazed and touched by Ivan Doig's gift. His words, and the way his phrases flow move me, and I am thankful for the many hours I have spent immersed in Mr. Doig's Montana. Although Heart Earth is basically a tale of discovery (or rediscovery), it is also a tale of hope, love and the eternal connection between a child and a parent, no matter what the circumstances or how far the distance in miles or years. If you've never read anything by this author, do yourself a favor: read every one of his books. Buy them in hardcover, keep them safe, and re-read them again and again. I have a special shelf in my personal library for his books, and I treasure every one of them. Thank you, Mr. Doig, for sharing your gift with me.

Rating:
Summary: Captivating
Review: This was my first Ivan Doig book, and after finishing it I immediately picked up This House of Sky. That the story springs forth from his mother's letters seems a fitting start for my experience with Ivan's books, to see how her moments of letter writing have spun themselves out through the words of her son in this book. The easy flow of his writing and the heart and feeling that flows with it (the little boy *kiting* down the prickly peared hill in Arizona) makes it great art--taking form as though it were always meant to be that way--unforced and uncontrived, as natural and beautiful as the Montana and the people he introduces us to. And I appreciate Ivan's own contributions to these review forums. As in this book and the House of Sky book, the love comes through. I have read both twice now (which I seldom do) and intend to keep them as a part of my library (which I also seldom do). I'm so glad I have found this writer and his books. Thank you, Ivan Doig, for sharing with us.