Rating: 
Summary: An excellent critique of American high school history texts
Review: Loewen reviews many of the American history textbooks most
commonly used in high school classrooms in recent decades.
In varying degrees they all fail in the important task of teaching history objectively and in an interesting manner.
Students come away with the false notion that American history
is one long boring epic tale of unblemished heroes who have contributed to the glorious nation in which we now have undiluted pride. Any negative notes are either ignored or downplayed as mere aberrations. With this kind of understanding
of history, it is little wonder that Americans are
constantly surprised by scandal and so easily misled by our "leaders". Every conscientious teacher, parent and citizen ought to read this book and work to reform the teaching of history in his/her school district.
Rating: 
Summary: Never called Called Conservatives "Stupid"
Review: One reviewer notes that Loewen calls the supporters of Goldwater and Reagan 'stupid,' citing pages 302-3. In fact, Loewen says nothing of the kind. Instead, Loewen says that when college students who have been poorly trained in history encounter sociological questions, their ineptness and disinterest may be thought of as the products and producers of 'social stupidity.' On the whole, the book is passionate and interesting. It may or may not have been written by a leftist, but it avoids being either left- or right-exclusive in its review of how American history has been and continues to be portrayed. At the very least, Loewen should be commended for initiating an interesting debate that, hopefully, will continue to take place between people who actually read the book.
Rating:
Summary: Read the whole thing.
Review: If when reading this book, you find that the author is completely one sided and biased, it's because you didn't read the next paragraph. The author shows the liberal view first, and gives the reader credit to keep reading to see the conservative side. Although I believe the topics and conclusions are largely liberal, they are fair and well balanced. I don't believe there is much to argue here.If you don't think the history referenced in this book is accurate, you are free to research it yourself. The author does not claim to use any secret sources. For instance, the author mentions that early european settlers dug up and ate dead native americans. I don't know where his source is for this, but I wouldn't be surprised if that source turned out to be primary source material. Whether or not the primary source is accurate, or corroborated, would also require more research. It would be embarrassing if the author just made it up, and judging by the topic of the book, counter-productive. Do yourself a favor and read the whole thing. Don't stop short like your teacher did with your history book.
Rating:
Summary: An amazing book
Review: This is am amazing look at not only the lies fed to american's youth as unquestiable truth, it also offers an interesting look at how history books are approved by state boards. Unlike "A People's History of the United States". This book can not be used as a "History Book" Or even as supplementary material. It does do the job of despelling certain lies well! For an adult interested in discover the long hidden lies this book is for you.
Rating:
Summary: What they won't teach you in history class
Review: From Christopher Columbus to the Vietnam war, most Americans hold beliefs that are either harmless myths at best, or outright lies at worst, and these have been taught to them in America's public schools. James W. Loewen's book demolishes many of them, along with other false icons, long held sacred by educators, parents, politicians--and taught to generations of school children as literal facts. Warning: don't read this book unless you are prepared to have some of your most cherished beliefs shattered. For example, we've all been taught or told how President Thomas Jefferson "doubled" the size of the United States with the Louisiana Purchase from France for 15 million dollars in 1803:
"Not one [history books] points out that it was not France's land to sell--it was Indian land. The Frence never consulted with the Native owners before selling; most Native Americans never even knew of the sale. Indeed, France did not really sell Louisiana for 15 mil. France merely sold 'it's claim' to the territory. The United States was still paying Native American tribes for Louisiana throughout the 19th century. We were also fighting them for it: the Army Almanac lists more than 50 Indian wars in the Louisana Purchase from 1819 to 1890"
Mr. Loewen's book is chock full of such nuggets of information. This is not a book of the author's opinions; the facts and conclusions drawn were culled from primary source materials, which anyone with the time and patience can check out for him or herself. "Lies My History Teacher Taught Me" should be taught in every public school at every grade level in the United States.
Rating:
Summary: This book changed my outlook permanently.
Review: This may well be the most important and singularly influential book I have read to date. It is that good.
Let me say that it was not perfect for my needs. It provided some new insights into the textbook publishing industry which, while interesting, were somewhat tangential to my reasons for reading it. It is all properly within the scope of the author's intent and labeled clearly as such. So I am not complaining.
The content was painful at times, even hard to believe. It was shocking. This feeling I had at first was explained by the book itself and not surprising by the end of the book. It is indeed the central thesis.
The history and new information which it did provide to me though, in such densely packed nuggets everywhere, were simply amazingly good. Furthermore, the author supports his facts thoroughly with references and little or nothing said in there is just to be simply believed and taken for granted. It is extremely well researched and supported by facts about which the author explicitly advises for readers to go find out more, from the original sources, as did the author himself.
The book succeeds in its purpose 100%. Very convincing. And I learned a whole lot along the way. The lessons are very, very timely.
Rating:
Summary: The cloud of History.
Review:
It is a fact that history has been distorted beyong recognition.
Reading "Retake Your Fame" by Aylmer von Fleischer, I learnt for the first time that Abraham Lincoln's Emancipation proclamation did not sst Blacks free. In fact, Lincoln was in a muddle over the Black situation. He even made plans to have Blacks resettled at the Ile de Vache (Cow Island) off the Haitian coast. The plan did not materialize, however.
Once, when Blacks were set free, Lincoln had them brought right back into slavery.
The Civil War in America was not fought to set Blacks free. It was all a matter of Economics, among other things.
Rating:
Summary: ** EVERY AMERICAN SHOULD READ THIS **
Review: The complexities of American History are easily described in detail and fact by the author throughout this book. Our historical leaders and triumphs are complex and 3 dimensional but are often described in 1 dimensional terms. Because of this Americans do not understand why their country has moved in the direction it has since its inception and many things do not make sense. Its like having a big puzzle with obvious puzzle pieces missing.
Case in point:
* Did you know that Hellen Keller was a radical feminist and a die hard socialist?
* Did you know how racist and sexist former President Woodrow Wilson was and how his policies underminded the rights of millions of Americans?
* Did you know there is a link between early European Christians spreading the gospel and the ablitiy to develop advanced weaponry which is one huge indicator of why European colonization was so prevelent and still is today?
This is just a smattering of the wealth of helpful and fascinating information that "The Lies My Teacher Told Me" covers. The book will help you fill in many of the blank puzzle pieces of American culture and history so that you may see the 'big picture'.
Rating:
Summary: Great book on historical perspective
Review: My god some of these reviews are dumb... JUST BECAUSE SOMEBODY SEEKS THE TRUTH, IT DOESN'T MAKE THEM A LIBERAL!
Not that there's anything wrong with being a liberal, but this isn't about liberal or right-wing- it's about portraying history truthfully. It's a good book, and it makes you think twice about heroification and glorification of historical figures. Definitely worth it.
Rating:
Summary: Tell Your Kids to Schedule History right after lunch
Review: James W. Loewen has written two very useful books here, the first a neat compilation of the top ten things that they never explained properly in high school history class and the second, all the cultural, political, and economic reasons why the educational system failed all of us.
Even those of us who consider ourselves well-versed in history need this refresher course. Loewen explains why Columbus's journey to the New World was not the first, but more importantly the last, in that it set in place the political and economic systems that we live under today. If they taught that Columbus was a slave-trader whose main contribution was the introduction of diseases that killed millions of indigenous folk, I don't remember that from my days at P.S. 116.
Loewen moves on deftly to more recent events, telling who Helen Keller really was (the leader of the American socialist and workers party) and why no one recalls or was ever taught anything about her except her rise from extreme adversity.
Then Woodrow Wilson appears, a native son of Virginia who re-introduced 19th century ways into 20th century Princeton and Washington, and did not mind a few foreign adventures along the way. The Russians still remember his meddling in their civil war, but it is long forgotten here. Loewen also enlightens us about the Mormons, John Brown, Jamestown, and the early Thanksgivings.
But enough history lessons. Loewen then moves into the area of his passion, which is why the US educational system avoids bad news, indiscretion, avarice, and conflict, and focuses instead on patriotism and the beneficial role of white men. The system is stacked against proper teaching of history for many reasons.
Most of the teachers have little education themselves in the subject, many being coaches with other committments. Few have the time or resources to develop their competency and all fear the type of open-ended teaching where they can be shown less than all-knowing.
Publishers are focused on best-selling textbooks, which requires acceptance by textbook advisory groups with patriotic and conservative agendas. Textbooks authors are typically college professors with no interaction with their readers and no system in place for peer review. Teachers prefer books with easy to use teaching aids such as pre-built exams, but have minimal say in book selection anyway.
Loewen has crafted a book that all who are interested in history and education should read. He is uniquely qualified, being an established historian with long experience in the textbook development, selling, and acceptance processes.
|
