The Member of the Wedding

Rating:
Summary: Obviously in the wrong age group...
Review: Carson McCullers has been my favorite author since I was thirteen and my father recommended I read a book by her. Now, four years later, I have read all of her short stories and all but one of her novels. By the reviews I have read, I believe maybe this book is not in the right category when it says "young adult" and should not be an option for a book report. Responding to this book with "whatever" and "no plot! " is not truthful and is a terrible injustice to it. This is a perfect "coming-of-age" novel, complete with the feeling of loss and the struggle to fit into pieces of a puzzle where you feel you do not belong. Typical McCullers - compassionate, painfully honest, and sensitive. While I'm obviously getting a little sappy, I do believe McCullers is the only author that I've ever read where I always feel like I am the protagonist - I felt like Frankie every word of this book, because McCullers creates the most realistic characters...let's be honest, kids - we were all "annoying", "selfish", "stupid", "unrealistic" and so on at the age of twelve.

Rating:
Summary: A Novel That Reads Like a Play
Review: I have read some of the other critiques of this novel, and it seems like people do not take into account the fact that this story takes place during WWII in a very small town and involves people of scant financial means and only basic education. With that in mind, it is not unlikely that a character like Frankie would develop and suffer the anguish of growing up. This complex novel would be better left to adults and not forced upon children in high school, for I can see how they would be frustrated in trying to read it. Anyway, this novel was apparently made into a play, and the book reads like one, with the three central characters taking center stage. McCullers' genius shines through this novel as well as The Heart is a Lonely Hunter. I highly recommend it.

Rating:
Summary: beautifully yet simply written
Review: My mother first bought me this book when I was 13. Now I'm 18 and I still love it, and I'm still amazed by the beauty in its style everytime I read it. It's the story of Frankie, a twelve year old girl without a mother who does not belong in her town. She feels like an outsider everywhere she goes. It's a concept that I totally related to when I first read the book. Frankie's older brother is planning a wedding, and the novel takes place in the days leading up to the wedding. Frankie, who longs for a way out of her small town and an escape from her life, can hardly wait for the wedding, which will take place in a town called Winter Hill. Frankie imagines how beautiful Winter Hill will be, and she begins to imagine that when her brother and the bride leave for their honeymoon after the wedding, they will take her along. This idea builds up so much in her mind that she can barely stand the anticipation, and she gets into some trouble. Overall, this book conveys Frankie's emotions and confusion so realistically that it's almost painful. But it's a wonderful book. The writing is beautiful, and there is so much imagery. One can picture the sweltering heat, the humidity, and it really helps the reader to get a sense of Frankie's inner frustration. This book is definitely worth reading.