Microsoft .NET XML Web Services

Rating:
Summary: Excellent book for the beginner to intermediate
Review: Finally, a book on .NET that the beginner can pick up and read without bewilderingly scratching his head. Robert's writing style is clear, consise, and really explains what's going on without droning on about complex, off-topic 'behind-the-scenes' code that's best left to the reference books.

As a budding C# programmer, I truly appreciate all the bi-lingual code Robert took pains in creating. These days, books typically pic one language and stick to it. The VB and C# folks certainly are treated equally here. And considering some of his content, I'd have a hard time in places if I were forced to convert VB into my own C#.

It's very well laid-out, the grammar and word choice is excellent, and is virtually never off-topic. It's obvoius to me that the intended audience is always kept in mind and the treatment is thorough enough that it can take a beginner from knowing very little about .NET to writing web services and clients along with describing the various technologies behind the .NET initiatives.

Rating:
Summary: Frustrating to go through the book
Review: I like the book's emphasis on consuming web services from different types of clients. The coverage on SOAP extensions is interesting.

However, going through the book has been very frustrating for the following reasons:

1) Code examples (on page 60, 154, 281, etc), instructions (on page 66, 77, etc), and notes (on page 79, 252, etc) failed on the Visual Studio.NET release version (also known as RTM - Release To Manufacturing). Looks like the book was based on VS.NET Beta. I wish the book had been up front by warning its readers. After all, people can no longer obtain VS.NET Beta.

2) Page 41 mentioned an URL for downloading the book's code samples. Thus, after encountering the first beta-related code error, I downloaded the online code samples. I was hoping that, after the book went to print, the code samples had been revised to work in the release version of VS.NET. But they were not! When I last checked on 10/May/2002, the errors were still in the online code samples.

3) Code samples (on page 60, 350, and 383) have syntax errors and therefore could not even compile in the way they were shown.

4) There are numerous text errors through out the book. The most glaring and incredible is the one in chapter 8. That chapter is supposed to examine the WSDL produced for code previously used in chapter 4 and 5. However, what was actually shown and commented on was the WSDL of code in chapter 2 and 3, not 4 and 5. What made the error even more confusing was the last paragraph on page 131. It said, "You might be wondering how developerEstimate and developerEstimateResponse got added to the [WSDL] document when they were not part of the original Web Service you created in Chapter 4 and 5. The .NET framework's created them..." For those who haven't read the book, "developerEstimate" was a Web Method in the Web Service created in chapter 2 and 3, but not in chapter 4 and 5. Chapter 4 and 5's Web Service does have a Web Method, but it is called "CalculateEstimate" on page 69.

5) It appears that not all of the recommended ways of doing things had been verified. For instance, chapter 19 recommended using WaitHandle.WaitAll in a Windows Form. But when the button2_Click code on page 315 was executed, Windows returned the error "WaitAll for multiple handles on an STA thread is not supported." That was because .NET Windows Forms use native Win32 Windows Forms which use Single Thread Apartment(STA) model.

Rating:
Summary: Great introduction to web services with ASP.NET
Review: I recently needed to quickly get "up to speed" on creating and using web services with ASP.NET. Although I was already very familiar with XML, SOAP, WSDL, etc., I found the explanations of how web services work to be very useful and understandable.

I also found that the sample code enabled me to easily create my own web services using ASP.NET. I appreciated that both VB and C# were included in the examples and discussions.

Overall, I found this to be a very practical, as well as understandable, introduction to ASP.NET and web services.

Rating:
Summary: Frustrating to go through the book
Review: Very easy to read, good all-around range of information regarding .net Web services. I am glad I picked this book up because it pertains specifically to web services in the new .NET environment.

Rating:
Summary: Great overall picture of xml web services with .net
Review: Very easy to read, good all-around range of information regarding .net Web services. I am glad I picked this book up because it pertains specifically to web services in the new .NET environment.