The Myths of Japanese Quality

Rating:
Summary: Wonderful TQM research tool
Review: I found this book is a must read for anyone doing research into Total Quality Management, (TQM), and Deming's theories. Anyone doing research into how Deming's theories are being promoted in public schools will really appreciate this book.

Rating:
Summary: Great read
Review: If you are into quality control this is a must read. I can't over emphasize that point. A friend of mine taught in Japan and told me the same horror stories the book reveals about the country and its practices. My ex girlfriend (who is Japanese and an anthropolgy major) also confirmed it. This just goes to show the power of the myth. Everyone has bought into this "japanese quality myth" hook, line and sinker. Its amazing.

Rating:
Summary: Provocative book.
Review: The Eberts combine their training in culture, quality issues,and their experiences in Japan into a readable book whicheffectively raises questions about just how Japan matches the US in many areas. The book uses their two perspectives well, and the combination is much better than either alone. Their conclusions about Japan are intriguing, and it would be interesting whether the ideas apply to China. I would guess that they do. In that case, the issues that the US faces in the near future are very serious, and must be brought into the general discussion.

Rating:
Summary: Looking for an insightful book about Japan? Look elsewhere
Review: The Eberts spent a total of, maybe four months living in Japan, and somehow they get a contract to publish this book. The book abounds with inaccuracies, stereotypes and self-preening. The tone of the book is, "These Japanese need some Americans to show them what to do..."

Noone can get a good handle on a culture in only four months. Especially if you don't speak the language, which neither of the Eberts do. There's a lot to drive you nuts in Japan, but for a reflective analysis of the culture, don't buy this book.