<< 1 >>
Rating: 
Summary: Tells the whole story..... up to '93
Review: Excellent journalism, no apologies for having a reasonable, disgusted and angry point of view. The oil, lumber and fish profiteers are uneasy with this expose'. The truth hurts, slimeballs! As an infrequent visitor to the Great Land for the last 30 years, I have alternately been outraged, amused, and flabbergasted at the idiotic and criminal ruin that "civilization" and "development" has brought. There are too few books like this.
Rating:
Summary: Tells the whole story..... up to '93
Review: Excellent journalism, no apologies for having a reasonable, disgusted and angry point of view. The oil, lumber and fish profiteers are uneasy with this expose'. The truth hurts, slimeballs! As an infrequent visitor to the Great Land for the last 30 years, I have alternately been outraged, amused, and flabbergasted at the idiotic and criminal ruin that "civilization" and "development" has brought. There are too few books like this.
Rating:
Summary: Disturbing, but quite factual
Review: Some reviews state that this highlights only the bad things associated with oil exploration in Alaska. This is just not true. The great wealth that came with the oil is accurately displayed - although with this wealth came just as many problems.This is a good look at exploration prior to Prudhoe Bay and the effect of ARCO's big hit on the Slope. Also there is good information on village life and the increasingly important subistence issue. No book on oil in Alaska would be complete without the Exxon Valdez and this is inlcuded. A must read for anyone interested in the history of oil exploration in Alaska! One problem - Mr. Strohmeyer begins the book fairly impartial. Unfortunately he (like the Alaska Daily News) allows himself to get caught up in the moment and DEFINATELY takes sides.
Rating: 
Summary: The seamy side of Alaska's state government
Review: Strohmeyer discusses the impact of the Alaskan oil boom on its state government and on its aboriginal peoples (Indians and others), covering the 1930s to 1992. There is also a brief 4-page epilogue dated '2003.' As other reviewers have pointed out, Strohmeyer approaches this from a pro-environmentalist, liberal perspective, but he's not a foaming-at-the-mouth leftist. For example, at times he shows empathy for the oil companies, and at times he's highly critical of unions, aboriginal organizations, and municipal governments under aboriginal control. All things considered, it's a well-written, thoughtful, and comprehensive documentation of how oil affected Alaskan politics. The author's theme is that the oil boom caused backroom deals and frivolous spending by the state government. However, any state government has similar dirty linen to hide, and I think Strohmeyer would have found the same anywhere, in both rich and poor states. Three of the 20 chapters are devoted to the 1989 oil spill by the Exxon Valdez, in which Exxon is portrayed as the villain. Yet, Strohmeyer's own description shows that the state government and the Coast Guard made things worse through bureaucratic bungling. What Strohmeyer neglects to mention is that Exxon had been forced to keep the Valdez's captain in place, despite his history of alcoholism, because his 'disability' caused him to be protected under anti-discrimination legislation. Exxon deserves much of the blame for the spill, but there's enough blame for everyone to share, including every Alaskan who has benefited from the oil windfall. Would Alaskans have wanted double-hulled ships even if it meant much lower Permanent Fund payments? There is a paradox here: The essence of political conservatism is that the public sector should be minimal because governments are always inefficient. By documenting how the Alaskan government squandered oil revenue (both political parties must share the blame), Strohmeyer has inadvertently made the conservative case that government should be as minimally involved in society as possible.
Rating:
Summary: What every congressman should know before opening ANWR
Review: This factual history of what happened after the North Slope was opened for oil drilling should serve as a warning. The greed and poor judgement demonstrated by Oil Corporations, Politicians, and Native governments is truly eye opening. With rising (by design?) gas prices the push to open the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge as well as the Reserves is on. With Babbitt, Stevens and other Alaskan pro drilling people in place in Washington it will be a fight to keep History from repeating itself. Strohmeyer lays it out. Even scarier is the wasteful clear cutting of lands held by the Native Corporations and the Economic support the federal government provides to make it possible. Everyone should read the book and then keep a close eye on the Dept. Of the Interior proposals.
Rating: 
Summary: Where's "The Rest of the Story"
Review: [This is a comment on the 1997 hardback edition.] Storhmeyer catalogues the worst of the events following the discovery of oil at Prudhoe Bay, but omits the overwhelming benefits. He has forgotten to tell "the rest of the story": The ability of the State of Alaska and local governments to provide amenities other Americans take for granted, such as sewer systems, flush toilets, clean drinking water, schools, roads, parks, and countless other benefits. Also missing are the individual stories of those who found jobs and hope when the US economy was in the doldrums. Finally, and most importantly, I find it frustrating to read the words of those who condemn the oil industry while enjoying the benefits of that industry: a warm house; a morning shower; synthetic clothing; driving and riding in automobiles; flying in jet aircraft; using computers; the benefits of modern medicine; etc. Where is this story to be found? If one wants to find villains, one can do so in any government, industry or association, or even disingenuous candidates for president. But any book purporting to tell the story of an event like the discovery of oil at Prudhoe Bay should include the whole story. Strohmeyer does not.
<< 1 >>
| 
