Santa Who?

Rating:
Summary: Santa Through the Ages
Review: It has been a while since this book crossed my desk, but I felt I had to give a more informative review than the only other review here to date. While I don't recall all the details of this book I do remember being impressed with the thorough examination of the changes through the centuries of the idea of Santa Claus. I felt this book would be a very good way for an elementary aged child to learn more about the history of Santa than what they see watching Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer every December. I am not partial to any organized religion, especially christianity, and I was not offended by this book because I felt it was fairly objective. The author presents a clear picture of all the different people and legends that contributed to our idea of who Santa is.

Rating:
Summary: not appropriate for reading in the public schools
Review: This book, while it might be OK for reading at home, was inappropriately read to my 2nd grader's class by some school librarian who apparently thought the whole world is, or should be Christian. On the second page of text, the author describes Jesus Christ as a saviour, which might be true, but this is not what I send my kids to school for. Unfortunately, some school systems allow any books to be read, and purchased if the librarian thinks they are needed. What is needed is some concern for the constitution of the United States here (in Barnard, Vermont!) I guess if you're looking for a book about Santa, this is as good as any, if you're looking for a book to read in school, this is not it!