Never Talk to Strangers (Family Storytime)

Rating:
Summary: It may be a sentimental favorite, but it's ridiculous.
Review: I purchased this book at the same time I purchased Protecting the Gift: Keeping Children and Teenagers Safe by Gavin De Becker. I read Never Talk to Strangers first, and was very disappointed. What do camels with bony knees, grouchy grizzly bears, parachuting hawks, a rhinoceros waiting for a bus, coyotes asking the time, and cars with whales at the wheel have to do with teaching my child about strangers - other than their ability to rhyme with the phrase "Never talk to strangers, please."?

After reading Protecting the Gift, I decided to return this book rather than share it with my 3 1/2 year old daughter, especially after the author specifically mentioned the book Never Talk to Strangers in a chapter about why merely teaching children not to talk to strangers doesn't work. I would rather teach my children that it is *strangeness* (inappropriate behavior that's relevant), not strangers, that can be dangerous.

Rating:
Summary: Book teaches difference between strangers and others
Review: This book was a part of my childhood collection and I loved it. Can't wait to see the updated illustrations. Strangers were always a tremendous and constant concern to my parents and I can say that this book was a great help in starting conversations and showing us the difference between a stranger and other people we encountered. As a teacher, mom and former child, I highly recommend this story. It is both effective and enjoyable.

Rating:
Summary: Don't take it so seriously!
Review: This is an old-time favorite book of mine, published the year I was born. I've waited a long time to find a copy for me to share with my child. The illustrations are fabulous and the rhymes keep kids giggling. It's a sweet message, but not one that's meant to teach all aspects of personal safety. I'll always love this book!