Rating: 
Summary: Too many errors
Review: Book has good content, but unfortunately has far too many errors for me to recommend. I can understand having errors but some are far too obvious to be excused. No doubt the author is very knowledgeable, but I hope in the future his work is more carefully edited.
Rating:
Summary: Too many errors
Review: Book has good content, but unfortunately has far too many errors for me to recommend. I can understand having errors but some are far too obvious to be excused. No doubt the author is very knowledgeable, but I hope in the future his work is more carefully edited.
Rating:
Summary: Not Accurate
Review: For a book to be used to teach people to use access-lists in Cisco hardware, this book contains entirely too many errors. The author should have either been more diligent or gotten a better (more Cisco knowledgable) proofreader. There are numerous ( I didn't bother to count) errors in both construction and application of the lists in this book.
Rating: 
Summary: Good information but cheap construction.
Review: I haven't had much time to read this book in depth yet, but the questions that I've needed answers to it has answered sufficiently. Why the 3 stars? The paper that this book is made from feels cheap, like the paper used in a $5 novel. I hope that O'Reilly isn't going to begin publishing all of their books with such shoddy materials.
Rating:
Summary: Good idea, good attempt. Bad tech editors and reviewers.
Review: I wouldn't recommend this book to novice network wizards. But for those who can see and identify errors, lets just consider this book as a tech quiz, a la "find and fix". It's been fun for me. Come on... It's impossible to know everything. Don't blame author. He has done a good work. He just didn't have a good support team. Yes, errors, yes, typos, and triple yes overall weight of all discrepancies almost ruin all other good impressions. But still, there are a lot of great and cool tips and tricks I have found.
Hope there will be another edition.
Rating: 
Summary: Worth the value
Review: Just received the book yesterday(March 4, 2002)and I'm at page 34 in Chapter 2 ... I was surprised to understand better the basics of Cisco IOS Access Lists that i haven't gained on CCNA study guide books. I believe that after reading the entire book, I'll gain the information i need in knowing Cisco IOS Access Lists as the way it should be. I recommend this book for those networking students and professionals who wish to take Cisco Certifications.
Rating:
Summary: Increasing my understanding of access lists.
Review: Nothing has become more important to computer networking than security, keeping out those things that are not need for the operations intended. O'Reilly Publishing has put together an excellent choice for administrators to help them ensuring that what needs to stay out stays out. Do not be fooled by the small size of the book or the fact that the book has only 250 pages, the manual is packed with information that is the key to creating and using access lists. Setting up security policies is just the beginning of the book and the very beginning to creating the access lists you'll need. From there you have a great breakdown of both standard and extended access lists. Policy writing for routing and security is the next topic discussed, the author makes sure that he has given more than enough information in each section. Troubleshooting Access lists is the next area followed up with IP Prefix lists, BGP Access lists, mapping for both interior and exterior lists. You'll also work with AS networks and there are appendices for both major port numbers and CIDR layouts. Also included is case studies to help you understand when, where and why to use access lists. Overall a very well done effort and a book that is making my job easier.
Rating: 
Summary: Good book, would be great with better editing
Review: This is a good book on Cisco IOS Access Lists, especially since there is only one other available in the market. Content is very good, as the author is knowledgable and has extensive experience. There are some errors, with better editing this book would have been worth 5 stars. Still worth reading since you can spot the errors once you have enough knowledge and use of access lists.
Rating:
Summary: Good book, would be great with better editing
Review: This is a good book on Cisco IOS Access Lists, especially since there is only one other available in the market. Content is very good, as the author is knowledgable and has extensive experience. There are some errors, with better editing this book would have been worth 5 stars. Still worth reading since you can spot the errors once you have enough knowledge and use of access lists.
Rating:
Summary: Good book to learn ACLs
Review: This just the book one would like to read to go through the basics of Cisco ACLs. The author introduces the concepts with some very simple and easily understandable examples. On the other hand, book is either a little outdated or author has intetionally not included many interesting ACL features. Features like turbo acls, dynamic acls, log input, extended communities are either not discussed or discussed very little in the book. The focus of the book is mostly control plane, the data plane is somewhat neglected. Overall a decent book, at best a book for a beginner. For someone new to acls this book will help save a lot of time understanding acls, route-maps, prefix-lists, communities, as paths ....
| 
