<< 1 >>
Rating: 
Summary: Great Creole Recipes
Review: Cajun and Creole cooking are often lumped together as a single cuisine. There is some justification for doing this, as there is a lot of overlap between the two cuisines, and they share many of the same dishes. However, they are not identical. If Paul Prudhomme represents the far Cajun end of the Cajun-Creole spectrum, Galatoire represents the far Creole end. Traditional Creole cooking, such as that served up in New Orleans at Galatoire's, Antoine's and Brennan's, is not the fiery hyper-spiced food of Prudhomme. Traditional Creole cooking is subtle, refined, and Continental in character. Seasonings are used merely to accent the flavor of the food, rather than to overwhelm it. Galatoire's book is an excellent example of this type of cooking. The recipes are delicious, suprisingly easy, and yes, even somewhat low in fat.
The chicken, shrimp, and ham jambalaya is nothing short of spectacular. My wife and I have cooked and eaten many different jambalayas, including recipes from Prudhomme, Justin Wilson, and from the excellent book by Terry Thompson. We have also had it in many restaurants in South Louisiana and elsewhere. We both agree that Galatoire's is the best we have ever tasted. His technique is somewhat unorthodox. The rice is cooked separately and then combined with the other ingredients for the last 10 minutes. This produces grains which are fluffy and separate, yet fully absorb the flavors of the meat, shellfish, vegetables, and seasonings. The Crawfish Etoufee, Shrimp Creole, and other recipes are also excellent.
So why did I only give it four stars? While the recipes are great, there are some problems with the mechanics and layout of the book. 1) There are a fair number of typos 2) The recipe for Crawfish Cardinal has you produce a stock as the first step, which is then never mentioned again in the recipe. 3) Recipes for sauces are in another part of the book from the recipes which call for them. Listing the page numbers for the sauces in the main recipes would have been helpful. 4) A few recipes are repeated verbatim in different chapters of the book (i.e. appetizers and main dishes). This seems awkward and unnecessary.
5) For a few recipes, a variation is described for the main recipe, and what is traditionally used is mentioned at the end. For example: Cobia Courtboullion is described. At the end of the recipe, Redfish is mentioned as what is traditionally used in South Louisiana. I would prefer to have the traditional recipe given first.
These problems are primarily editorial and easily fixed. I would love to see Galatoire come out with a competently edited second edition of this book. I believe it would become a classic among Cajun-Creole cookbooks.
In conclusion, despite the problems mentioned, the recipes in this book are great and make it well worth owning. If you love Creole cooking and prefer flavor to heat, buy this book!
Rating: 
Summary: What a Find
Review: I have been going to Galatoire's since I was a young child. On a recent trip to New Orleans, my husband and I were lucky enough to find this cookbook. As a wonderful birthday surprise, my husband made the stuffed eggplant. As anyone who has had the stuffed eggplant at Galtoire's knows, the name of the dish is a misnomer. The stuffed eggplant is a wonderful gastronomic event filled with shrimp and crabmeat. Later we made the crabmeat au gratin with the leftover crabmeat - it was sublime. I am looking forward to trying some of my other favorite dishes from the restaurant such as the crab maison and oysters en brochette. Anyone who has been to Galatoire's knows there are no descriptions of the food -- only names and prices. One of the things I love about the book is knowing what some of the dishes are. I will surely sample more on my next visit to New Orleans. Galatoire's is an institution and I am so pleased to have some of their recipes.
Rating: 
Summary: Very dissapointing! Unaccurate and incomplete directions!
Review: I own several cookbooks on Louisiana and Creole cuisine. I have been cooking since I am a teenager and I consider it my main hobby. The book includes typical Louisiana and Creole dishes (I am originally from Germany but live in Louisiana, so I can tell) and it also features Galatoires own creations. I cooked the Read Beans and rice and the fluid measure did not match up by far. I was suspicious from the beginning and used less then Galatoires recommends. I still had to scoop out lots of access gravy. This was very dissapointing. Obviously nobody test cooked this recipe, otherwise it would have been obvious. I am aware that cooking with an open / close pot and the soaking of the beans may make a difference in the need for fluid but this was sure more than a quart too much fluid! I also cooked the pork tenderloins with mango-apple salsa. It does not tell if the tenderloins have to go in the oven covered or uncovered. How is one supposed to know? It does not tell how to slice (size) the mango for the salsa. Following the recipe in detail the salsa was very dry, far from a sauce or salsa. The mango was pulpy in no time and the apple 1/8 were still much too hard. (If I would be asked, the apple should go first and later the mango). I also don't like the "salt to taste" Galatoires uses in the book. Especially for a beginner this is not enough. (The book states that it is easy, even for beginners). Besides the lack of taste (which is a matter of taste) this recipe also misses to tell us what to eat with the tenderloins. I would expect suggestions for a side dish! How is a beginner supposed to know what goes well with it? Now to the more personal taste things: I have been to Galatoires Restaurant several times and enjoyed the food a lot. I have the feeling that the chefs don't cook out of this book, otherwise the restaurant could not hold its standards. The recipes are not spicy enough and try to follow a more modern (lean) diet. Louisiana and Creole kitchen is a tasty-rich kitchen and should therefore not be leaned out. (It is ridicoulous when the author writes in the recipe text that one can enjoy pork every now and then if you exercise enough etc.: I don't want to know that, this is not a book on nutrition! The author would better tell us in detail how to prepare the things!) The book has no illustrations, e. g. on how the famous "roux" has to look like and no illustrations on the dishes. It is too expensive and I overall feel like this book is there to make money rather then to teach us the tricks and finesse of New Orleans kitchen! PS: If you are interested in a more precise and sophisticated book on Louisiana Kitchen, you should read: Paul Prudhomme: "Chef Paul Prudhomme's Louisiana Kitchen".
Rating:
Summary: Cookbook review
Review: I received a gift of Galatoire's cookbook. I've only recently had a chance to try a couple of his recipes, and they were perfect for the palatte. I first tried the Creole Sauce on p. 110 This was so tasty and we loved the spicy tomato flavor on our bake pork chops. I made a full recipe and froze the loftovers to use another time. I appreciated having all the sauce recipes located in one area of the book-a great time saver. The second selection was on p. 24-Grilled Chicken Breast Belize. Mmmm good. The chicken had a flavorful nutty taste and so tender it melted in your mouth. For a Louisiana native these selections were true to the area cuisine. I found both recipes easy to follow and produced mouth-watering results.
Rating:
Summary: Comment to review from Baton Rouge, La., U.S.A.
Review: I was born and raised in South Louisiana, in the town of Buras. I fined your opinion concerning the red beans and rice recipe completely inaccurate. If you read the package your hard red beans come in you will find they call for between 8 and 10 cups of water. Further more this is the way my grandmother, being of cajun ascent, has prepaired her red beans for many years with outstanding results, at home and church gatherings. Red beans and ricely yours Barry Brooks
<< 1 >>
|
