Home :: Books :: Entertainment  

Arts & Photography
Audio CDs
Audiocassettes
Biographies & Memoirs
Business & Investing
Children's Books
Christianity
Comics & Graphic Novels
Computers & Internet
Cooking, Food & Wine
Entertainment

Gay & Lesbian
Health, Mind & Body
History
Home & Garden
Horror
Literature & Fiction
Mystery & Thrillers
Nonfiction
Outdoors & Nature
Parenting & Families
Professional & Technical
Reference
Religion & Spirituality
Romance
Science
Science Fiction & Fantasy
Sports
Teens
Travel
Women's Fiction
 The Eugenics Wars Vol. 2:  The Rise and Fall of Khan Noonien Singh (Star Trek)

The Eugenics Wars Vol. 2: The Rise and Fall of Khan Noonien Singh (Star Trek)

List Price: $24.95
Your Price: $17.46
Product Info Reviews

<< 1 2 3 4 >>

Rating: 5 stars
Summary: Cox mixes recent history with Star Trek mythos....
Review: Khan.

Although Star Trek has pitted its various starships and space station crews against such formidable antagonists as the Klingons, the Romulans, the Borg, and the Xindi, few of them have had such an indelible persona as Khan Noonien Singh, a genetically engineered "superman" who, according to the Original Series episode "Space Seed" and the 1982 feature film Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan, ruled one-quarter of the Earth during a period called the Eugenics Wars. As Khan says to Chekov in Star Trek II, "On Earth, 200 years ago, I was a prince, with power over millions."

Whereas Greg Cox's first novel in a two-book cycle sets up the whole Khan backstory (he's the product of an ambitious attempt by brilliant but twisted scientists to "improve" humanity by tinkering with human DNA) by mixing real Earth history from 1974 to 1989 and Star Trek lore, Volume Two tells the story of Khan Noonien Singh at the very height of his power, his failed attempt to unite his genetically engineered brothers and sisters under his banner, and his ultimate exile aboard the DY-100 sleeper ship he will name, aptly, SS Botany Bay.

Although there is a thematically-linked "frame story" set during Capt. Kirk's first five-year mission about the Enterprise investigating a colony of genetically engineered humans that has applied for membership in the Federation, Cox's main storyline focuses on Agent Gary Seven and Roberta Lincoln's attempts to stop Khan -- who had briefly worked them in their mission to save Earth from a third world war but then fell out with Seven and followed a darker path -- from blowing up the planet and destroying humanity. To tell this important story in the Star Trek mythos without having the 21st Century reader rolling his or her eyes and going, "Yeah, right. If the Eugenics Wars happened in the '90s, why didn't I hear about it on CNN?" Cox has incorporated the Balkan Wars, the rise of militias in the United States, the "Black Hawk Down" ambush in Mogadishu, and almost every major crisis in the mid-1990s and meshes it with Star Trek "history," which thankfully was not very detailed in the 1967 episode that introduced Khan.

As he does so well in Volume One, Cox blends an exciting Star Trek adventure -- full of references to established "facts" and characters from various movies and series episodes -- with real historical events that took place from 1992 to 1996. He slyly makes social commentary about our recent past and allusions to other famous movies and television series, including an homage to Ricardo Montalban's (Khan) most famous TV role.

The pace is fast and Cox's style is very engaging. He apparently loves Star Trek and its characters, and it clearly shows in this exciting and entertaining series of novels. I strongly recommend this two-book series to Star Trek fans and even non-fans.

Rating: 4 stars
Summary: Eugenics Wars 2
Review: A very satisfying conclusion to what we got treated to in Volume 1...however, this book suffers from being somewhat more predictable than its predecessor, mainly because the author is stuck having to work towards a predestined finale, that must set things up cleanly for Star Trek: TOS's "Space Seed" story. Any problems inherent in Volume 2 are an extension of this basic difficulty. Gary Seven, to my disappointment, only appears sporadically in this installment, and his main purpose here is to concoct a last-ditch plan to curb Khan without executing him (Seven does not like to kill), and, of course, this plan leads to "Space Seed". Meanwhile, Roberta Lincoln takes center stage--she's got guts, this fine lady, taking all the tough jobs when it comes to foiling Khan and his super-troopers whenever she can. This is terrific when it comes to showing Roberta at her finest, in endless dangerous and unpredictable situations, but taken as a whole, her decades-spanning exploits come off as a bit helter-skelter. I would like, in future, to see Roberta Lincoln in an adventure that doesn't require as much jumping around--something with unity of time, place and action.

Then there's Khan. Because The Eugenics Wars novels take the daring approach of trying to "fit" Khan into what we know to be our own history, while at the same time having him live out a scenario that sees him become "a prince, with power over millions", the Eugenics Wars are really a prolonged Secret War. And yet Khan does gain power over millions, so no, he's not a liar in the film Star Trek 2: The Wrath of Khan. Frankly, I would not have minded if these books had abandoned the secret-war approach the farther along Khan's bid for power went; I would have liked to see him become more of a world-ruler, overtly grabbing up power before his great fall. Anyway, no worries, concerning the ultimate melding of truth and fiction, with an emphasis on trying to depict Eugenics Wars that come close to being something that could have actually happened in the mid-90s we really experienced. My one extra quibble is that in Volume 2, Khan is perhaps not cruel enough--in two different instances he backs down from certain aggressive activity, showing him as surprisingly marshmallowy when it comes to getting talked out of his vilest plans, and also a bit too sympathetic towards the general population, considering how bitter he appears to be. Again, Khan is at the mercy of pre-established continuity, plus any strictures automatically placed on him by these books' stubbornness over inserting him into 1996 as it really occurred.

Despite my negative remarks, I heartily encourage anyone seeking dazzling, action-packed SF to check out the rise and fall of Khan Noonien Singh. Delightful reading.

Rating: 5 stars
Summary: Khan bids to take over world in 1990s...alert CNN!
Review: One of the reasons Star Trek has lived long and prospered has been its memorable characters and storylines, not to mention the way it has developed a sense of continuity. The sense that the various captains, crews, starships, even a space station live in a believable universe not only comes from Gene Roddenberry's original concept of setting his original series at a time when faster-than-light travel might be possible, but from script writers that had the talent and the imagination to create a back story to Starfleet, the starship Enterprise, the Federation, and Earth's "past" -- from the characters' 23rd/24th Century vantage points. By citing such events as the Romulan Wars, first contact with the Klingons, and the Eugenics Wars of the late 20th Century, Star Trek's writers create a subconscious feeling in the viewer's (or reader's) mind that yes, that universe has a history that is believable and adds much to the dramatic story's emotional impact.

Because Star Trek's writers chose to set the original series in a believable future scenario rather than creating a "galaxy far, far away" a la George Lucas, they wrote several episodes that dealt with what in the mid-1960s was still the future. Two of them, including "Assignment: Earth," involved time travel by Capt. Kirk and the USS Enterprise to the Sixties, while "Space Seed," by Carey Wilbur and Gene L. Coon, established the history of the Eugenics Wars of the 1990s.

Obviously, the writers of the episode had no idea that Star Trek would become such a long-lived franchise or that a feature film would be based on "Space Seed," yet Khan Noonien Singh -- one of Ricardo Montalban's most memorable roles -- and the events of his era loom large in the Trek scenario. So how does a writer of contemporary Trek -- whether it is on film or the printed page/e-book -- reconcile what was the 1960s "future" with our very real and stormy past in a believable way?

In my review of Volume One of Star Trek -- The Eugenics Wars: The Rise and Fall of Khan Noonien Singh I mentioned that author Greg Cox (Assignment: Eternity) chose to focus his two-volume series not on the captain and crew of the NCC-1701 (although they have a relevant "frame" storyline that acts as a launching pad for the "historical's" main narrative) but on the efforts of Gary Seven and Roberta Lincoln to save Earth from a major world war as the now-adult children of the Chrysalis Project fight among themselves for world supremacy.

Obviously, the outcome (Khan attempts to conquer world, fails, and is exiled with 90 or so of his genetically superior brothers and sisters aboard the advanced DY-100 sleeper ship SS Botany Bay, to be found 300 years later by Kirk's Enterprise in the Mutara Sector) is never in doubt. No, the fun in reading Cox's novels is in seeing how he manages to blend Star Trek's established history with our own recent past.

After a 23rd Century prologue that continues Kirk's now imperiled investigation of the Paragon Colony on the planet Sycorax (the Klingons have sabotaged the colony and Kirk must find a way to save the genetically engineered humans' skins, as well as those of his own landing party), Cox returns to the 20th Century, this time during the critical early 1990s, at a time when the post-Cold War era is marked by wars in the Balkans and elsewhere, the rise of the "militia" movement in the United States, and all the other events that made the Nineties "a strange, violent time," as Spock says in the original 1967 episode. Cox manages to convincingly portray the unconnected headlines (Revolutionary turmoil stirs in Peru; Ethnic hatred plunges Yugoslavia into civil war!) as part of the Star Trek universe's Eugenics Wars.

Volume Two is just as exciting and funny as the first installment of the series, with more action and inside jokes and references to the culture of the time period, other Trek histories (even Jonathan Archer gets a mention in this one), and even a knowing little homage to Ricardo Montalban's best known TV role ("Welcome, Miss Lincoln, to Chrysalis Island!").

Rating: 4 stars
Summary: Excellent backhistory.
Review: In the original "Star Trek" series, one of the most famous and powerful episodes was "Space Seed", in which the crew of the Enterprise met and came into conflict with Khan Noonien Singh, a survivor from the "Eugenics Wars" of the "distant past" of the 1990s. Now that we have, in fact, bumbled our way through those 1990s without an apparent destructive struggle with Khan and his crowd of genetically engineered supermen, the standard wisdom says that the "backhistory" of the Star Trek universe has become dated; what seemed like a possible future in the late '60s has failed to come to pass.

What this book (and its predecessor) attempt to do is to reconcile the facts given in that episode (and its movie sequel) with the actual history of the previous decade. This might seem impossible, but in fact is managed quite nicely; the machinations of the genetically enhanced would-be world conquerors mostly happened behind the scenes, and was kept out of the mainstream press, in a way that seems far more plausible than might be expected. Further, the characterizations were handled well, and the writing style is excellent.

The only reason that I mark the book down a star is that the "frame story" format, in which the first chapter and the last detail a minor adventure of Kirk and the Enterprise, simply to provide a bit of "face time" for the major characters who some fans might feel cheated without, was basically irrelevant to the main story. I'd have preferred to see the main story told as a stand-alone, with the secondary story fleshed out and given its own book. As it stands, it was just a distraction.

Rating: 2 stars
Summary: Another Star Trek Rewrite
Review: Part I of this series was quite entertaining, but this one isn't what I hoped for. It's another example of rewriting the Star Trek universe in a vain attempt to fit reality. It doesn't suprise me, because this novel fits perfectly into the philosophy of the new Trek series.
I gave it two stars because it did fit reality in a somewhat clever fashion, but as someone else already stated, it didn't happen this way.

Rating: 1 stars
Summary: for juvenile trekkies only
Review: I hoped these books would be good, but Cox is just plain awful. Full of cute little references to every Trek series, plus inane pop culture references for every time period covered... I sighed many times, and often had to put the book down in disgust.

If you are an insufferable trekkie nerd or just have very low expectations, maybe you can stomach this drivel. If you want intelligent sci-fi, look elsewhere.

Rating: 4 stars
Summary: Always Mentioned But Never Explained
Review: In the classic episode "Space Seed", Khan mentions The Eugenics War and how he and his men were transformed into "Supermen" and at the same time were the only ones to survive it by being put into stasis. Centuries later, Kirk and crew find that "ship" and mistakenly awake Khan and his crew.

Khan was a great foe to Kirk. Always could outsmart Kirk and never was able to be defeated until that is Kirk set a trap for him and left him and his men on a desolate planet to die (Star Trek 2: The Wrath of Khan happens because of this)

Greg Cox, likes writing long long chapters but is nevertheless a wonderful writer. Although I'm quite curious as to how another seasoned writer (Peter David perhaps?) would have imagined this war.. All in all it is about time that it is being explained in Star Trek Land though it would have been better had it been explained on one of the Trek series. Why it wasn't is beyond me...

Archer and crew are you listning?

Rating: 5 stars
Summary: Now we get to the meat of the story...
Review: Volume One was the set up, the cheese and crackers, but in volume two we finally get to the beef and potatoes, the main course. We watch as Khan goes up against Gary Seven, Roberta Lincoln and the rest of the planet INCLUDING his own super-brothers and super-sisters who refuse to follow him. What will Khan do when he realizes that he won't be allowed to rule the Earth? And how can anybody stop him?
Khan is shown as a ruthless, reckless, yet thoughtful leader, who cares for his own people and, at first, most of the world. But he, like most of us, slowly comes to the understanding that Earth's problems are not easy to solve and its people are not easy to handle.
Better than the first volume!

Rating: 3 stars
Summary: Good, for Trek Fiction
Review: Trek books are a guilty pleasure, bubblegum for the brain, a good book for a plane flight or train trip. Cox's book fits into that pattern. Nothing challenging, but worth the read.

Geeks will enjoy spotting the plethora of Star Trek, comics, tv show, and movie homages scattered through the book. I suspect I didn't get more that 60% of what's there.

On the downside -- the author wears his politics on his sleeve, especially when dealing with one of Khan's brethern, a paranoid American who creates a militia "cult". While a distaste for conservate politics and for law-abiding firearms owners is likely good Trek-politics, the book takes gratiutious slams by lumping all firearms owners in with a few over-the-top folks. This is especially grating when Gary Seven gives a speech about trusting to ordinary human ability and judgment and the risk of folks who think that because of their DNA they are "better" than others. The same should apply to those who think that just because they are alien-spy-agents they are more responsible with firearms than average folks.

Some of the global political material was also shallow, but one should go not to Trek books for deep thinking on current events.

I would have liked it better with less modern politics and more allegory.

Rating: 3 stars
Summary: OK read, but too conventional
Review: I really liked the first volume. It was steeped in lore and "fictional history" with enough real history folded in to set the stage. Unfortunately, I felt that volume 2 worked too hard to fit Trek history into real history. It's an OK read. Not terribly thought provoking. I was expecting to see events unfold as described in historical references to the past when mentioned in the Trek franchise, to see how real history differed from Trek history.


<< 1 2 3 4 >>

© 2004, ReviewFocus or its affiliates