Rating: 
Summary: Good but not great
Review: This is the first book I have read on the First World War. It is written like a well researched newspaper article. Martin Gilbert seems to give all the key facts in chronological order, with helpful maps and well chosen photographs. He describes many of the ironies of the war (such as the poems written by the soldiers) and weaves into the story a description of where virtually all of the important figures of the Second World War were and what they did that foreshadowed their later actions. I was fascinated to learn how the First World War was occurring on several fronts in Europe, Asia, Africa and the Middle East. The author, who is apparently English, focuses on England's role, and describes the American contribution as pivotal but minor. However, the author glosses over the strategies being used by the leaders of the countries in conflict. He does little to provide a historical context for the war, such as how the populace of the participant countries perceived the war. The writing is not captivating, such as it was in James MacPherson's Battle Cry of Freedom. Still, it was enjoyable and informative.
Rating: 
Summary: Inconsistent narrative
Review: While Gilbert paints a vivid picture of the war and its effects on both individuals and the nations that participated in it, he constantly shifts his focus from myopic anecdotal accounts to high level overviews of the events that occurred. His account of the war would have been much more readable had he been more consistent in his historiographical methodology. As with so many other historical accounts that cover specific events, this book would have benefited from the input of a competent editor.
Rating:
Summary: An essential work
Review: While true that there are flaws, who could expect a complete history of the Great War in 600 pages, this is an essential work for anyone interested in the war that was a suicide of Europe. A war that has forever changed the West and turned the French into what they are today. Very well done. Yes, the proof reading in the hardcover volume is bad, that is not the author's fault. Shame on the publisher for that problem. Gilbert touches on real persons, the men in the trenches. His often poignant use of letters and poetry written by these men bring real flesh and blood to the pages. Poetry written by unknown writers and well known men who, amidst the dread, sparkle with humanity. Highly recommended.
For the most complete history you will have to lug around several volumes written by Hew Strachan. Volume I: To Arms comes in at over 1200 pages, including 50 pages of bibliography and the index.
| 
