<< 1 >>
Rating: 
Summary: A real view
Review: A real eye opener.This is real alternate history. Each of the selected articles could actually have happened. Though I do have my reservations on how the Germans might have reacted to a Soviet Invasion. Adolf Hitler had a habit of demanding Stand and Fight Regardless of situation, such as Stalingrad. More German soldiers probably died because of his lack of insight than allied military genius. And the sight of Rommel just exploding at the sights of Dachau, like his American counterparts did after the war. Dachau was not that bad yet. Auschwitz or Majdanek would have been a better place to put him in scene. Over all, this is a great book on what could have been had chance gone a different direction.
Rating: 
Summary: Interesting in parts
Review: I enjoy alternative histories and thought this might be up my alley. It's structure parallels the book "What If?" wherein various authors write short vignettes about possible historical outcomes. There are several alternatives to WWII, many of them interesting, but most contain so much military hardware detail that it interferes with the plot. I was looking forward to something of the post-war experience but alas, these are almost all written from the perspective of the combatant....
Rating:
Summary: Interesting in parts
Review: I enjoy alternative histories and thought this might be up my alley. It's structure parallels the book "What If?" wherein various authors write short vignettes about possible historical outcomes. There are several alternatives to WWII, many of them interesting, but most contain so much military hardware detail that it interferes with the plot. I was looking forward to something of the post-war experience but alas, these are almost all written from the perspective of the combatant....
Rating: 
Summary: Standard Alternate History
Review: Nothing really special here, folks. A standard series of scenarios on an alternate history topic that's been done to death. On the other hand, most of the scenarios are decently written, and some are actually quite original. If you enjoy this book, you should also enjoy its companion book, Rising Sun Victorious, by the same author.
Rating:
Summary: Mostly solid collection of alternate histories
Review: Third Reich Victorious is a collection of alternate history stories (companion to Rising Sun Victorious) about World War 2. It contains ten stories of alternate outcomes, with either the Germans winning in Europe or else still losing, but having it take much longer to finish the war. Most of the stories are thoughtful and interesting, although a few stretched belief. For instance, in the first one, Germany wins through sea power where a young Hitler becomes a naval officer rather than in the infantry. He also loses his racism against the Jews after a lecture by an admired NCO. Basically, it's not the same Nazi Germany here. Well that seems easy to write, when everything is different. I prefer alternate stories where you're basically dealing with the same personalities and they just happen to make a different choice than they did historically, or they excute better. There are many well written stories here though and all stories are well footnoted, which the reader will appreciate greatly. Very nice.
Rating:
Summary: Mostly solid collection of alternate histories
Review: Third Reich Victorious is a collection of alternate history stories (companion to Rising Sun Victorious) about World War 2. It contains ten stories of alternate outcomes, with either the Germans winning in Europe or else still losing, but having it take much longer to finish the war. Most of the stories are thoughtful and interesting, although a few stretched belief. For instance, in the first one, Germany wins through sea power where a young Hitler becomes a naval officer rather than in the infantry. He also loses his racism against the Jews after a lecture by an admired NCO. Basically, it's not the same Nazi Germany here. Well that seems easy to write, when everything is different. I prefer alternate stories where you're basically dealing with the same personalities and they just happen to make a different choice than they did historically, or they excute better. There are many well written stories here though and all stories are well footnoted, which the reader will appreciate greatly. Very nice.
<< 1 >>
| 
