SAPPERS IN THE WIRE

Rating:
Summary: EXCELLENT WORK
Review: AASIGNED TO COMPANY "D" 1/46, 196 INF, I KNOW MR. NOLAN HAS TONS IF INTERVIEWS AND DOCUMENTS ON THE SUBJECT, FSB MARY ANN, I BELIEVE THAT VOLUMES COULD AND SHOULD BE WRITTEN AS WELL AS PHOTS, NOT TO STOP SHORT OF A FEATURE FILM.....

Rating:
Summary: I was featured in the book. My name is Dennis Murphy and thi
Review: I agree totally with the previous reviewer that this should be required reading in the War Colleges of all the services. I was a MACV infantry advisor who pulled into LZ MaryAnne with two companies of my ARVN battalion the night before the NVA attack. I can remember clearly sitting on top of a bunker, looking at the hills that surrounded the firebase within easy mortar range and thinking that this was probably the stupidest place I'd ever seen to put a firebase. Added to that was the obviously slack discipline of the line grunts and the seeming lack of interest of their officers and I have to admit I was glad to get out of there the next morning. When the NVA assault broke out that evening, we were over 12 klicks away and all I could do was listen to it on the radio and shake my head at the waste of lives that I knew was taking place. Eleven years later when I met some of the survivors at a reunion that accompanied the dedication of the Vietnam Veteran Memorial, I was only slightly surprised to find that they agreed with my opinions on the battle.

Rating:
Summary: I was featured in the book. My name is Dennis Murphy and thi
Review: The war was winding down but for the men of the 196th LIB home was just a distant dream. As a member of Charlie Company, I can attest to the accuracy and fairness the author treats the grunts of LZ MaryAnn. I only pray that we will never see a war like VN again.

Rating:
Summary: I was there
Review: This book helped me remember how lucky I am to be here to read it. I was amazed at how much detail he found in his research, best one Ive read on viet nam and what it was really like. Thanks mr. Nolan

Rating:
Summary: Many died in their sleep when they should have been awake.
Review: This is the true story of the destruction of Fire Support Base Mary Ann by a Viet Cong sapper company which was able to penetrate the outer perimeter wire undetected, because no one was awake in any of the bunkers. It was 1971, and nobody wanted to be the last GI killed in Vietnam. Officers and NCOs became complacent about night time security, otherwise this event shouldn't have been as deadly an attack as it was. Skillfully written, and exceptionally well documented, it is must reading for any career officer and NCO about the need for following seurity SOPs religiously. Keith William Nolan rightly has been credited as a "master of the personal interview," and his book brings out the best and worst in what went wrong the night of 27-28 March 1971. This is a story that you won't soon forget.