<< 1 >>
Rating: 
Summary: As unbalanced as modern historiography is likely to get
Review: Alden Vaughan tackles the initial years of colonization in New England by the Puritans, and the relationship their communities had with the Native Americans of the region. In his examination, Vaughan argues that contrary to generally accepted histories, the Puritans' relations with the Native American groups in political, economic, judicial and religious spheres was "relatively humane, considerate and just," when compared with other contemporary European colonies in the New World, particularly the English colony in Virginia. The evidence that Vaughan provides is almost entirely drawn from Puritan sources, with some corroboration taken from other European colonies whenever possible. According to Vaughan no written histories from this period exist relating the Native American perspective directly, and he is confident that the Puritans left generally unbiased records regarding their dealings with the various native nations and individuals. The text he has produced from his investigation is one which sheds a considerably softer light on the Puritan's motives and actions regarding the Native Americans in New England.
Vaughan's argument is generally convincing given the sources he examines. Vaughan defends his reliance on Puritan sources eloquently in the Preface, and it is hard to deny that there is a lack of Native American sources from the Puritan era. Still, there is no question that an unfiltered Native American voice is lacking, and that must be taken into account when assessing Vaughan's evidence. One wonders why Vaughan did not look into the writings of the Christian Native Americans living in New England, or further delve into the conversion narratives which he refers to. Vaughan has also avoided using captivity narratives written by Puritans, another possible source of information regarding Native American culture and opinion. Another inherent problem is Vaughan's narrow time span; this work focuses on a generation and a half of English/Native American interaction, and thus the lasting implications of Puritan policy are for the most part disregarded. Also lacking is gendered analysis of both Native American and Puritan relations; while Vaughan does briefly cover women's roles in Native American society in Chapter II, Puritan women are overlooked entirely in his predominately political analysis, as are "Praying Indian" women and their adjustment to Puritan gender roles. Overall, Vaughan mounts a convincing defense of the Puritan's motives and conduct, but one can come away from his work with the impression that in Vaughan's eyes, the Puritans could do no wrong.
Rating: 
Summary: Tribes and Colonies
Review: In 1620 the English Puritans settled in the region they called New England. There they met the natives, the Indians. This book explains how the Puritans and Indians related with each other until 1675. Vaughan demonstrates that the Puritans did not exploit the Indians as often believed but dealt fairly with them. He neither denigrates nor whitewashes either the Puritans or the Indians, but is fair to both sides. Vaughan describes the Indians, their beliefs and customs, and what they thought of the Puritans. Vaughan also portrays the beliefs and customs of the Puritans and their attitudes towards the Indians. Vaughan recounts how the Puritans and the Indians allied together to destroy the aggressive Pequot tribe in the Pequot war in 1637.
Vaughan sketches the trade between Puritans and Indians, at first trading furs for items and later for wampum. Then he describes how the Puritans tried to fit the Indians fairly into their legal system. Finally he recounts the Puritans attempts to convert the Indians to Christianity. This is an excellent account, based on extensive primary and secondary sources, of the little known period before King Philips attack on the Puritans changed how the colonists and the Indians saw each other.
Rating: 
Summary: Excellent and balanced
Review: This is the most balanced account of the relationship between the Indians and the early settlers I have read. It is an excellent book for someone who is interested in both sides of the story, Indian and Puritan. Vaughan tries to portray the truth of both people's viewpoint and doesn't get bogged down in politically correct rambling so prevalent in modern renditions (i.e. Greg Nobles). A must read for those who desire to be balanced in their view of History.
Rating:
Summary: Excellent and balanced
Review: This is the most balanced account of the relationship between the Indians and the early settlers I have read. It is an excellent book for someone who is interested in both sides of the story, Indian and Puritan. Vaughan tries to portray the truth of both people's viewpoint and doesn't get bogged down in politically correct rambling so prevalent in modern renditions (i.e. Greg Nobles). A must read for those who desire to be balanced in their view of History.
<< 1 >>
| 
