<< 1 >>
Rating: 
Summary: A typo in hardcovers
Review: Removing all the text in this Farsi farce would only be an improvement.
Rating:
Summary: A Poorly written book
Review: This is a very poorly written book. There are hundreds of spelling and grammatical errors. I can't believe a publisher actually printed this book, or that nobody with some education proofread it before it was published. The book seems to be a collection of drawings, extracts from other books or articles, and another book (perhaps in Farsi from the same author). It is a mix bag of disjointed short description of stories from Shahnameh (the legendary / mythical history of the ancient Iran) and the history of the Persian Empire. The pages, the stories, and the whole book do not flow together. I do not know that much about the subject itself, but I suspect that there are a lot of wrong information in the book as well.
Rating:
Summary: A Poorly written book
Review: This is a very poorly written book. There are hundreds of spelling and grammatical errors. I can't believe a publisher actually printed this book, or that nobody with some education proofread it before it was published. The book seems to be a collection of drawings, extracts from other books or articles, and another book (perhaps in Farsi from the same author). It is a mix bag of disjointed short description of stories from Shahnameh (the legendary / mythical history of the ancient Iran) and the history of the Persian Empire. The pages, the stories, and the whole book do not flow together. I do not know that much about the subject itself, but I suspect that there are a lot of wrong information in the book as well.
Rating: 
Summary: It taught me much about Iranian civilization
Review: This is realy my first book I am reading on Iran and the great Persian history. It gave me a great insight of the pre-islamic Iran. I agree that the book is not well edited. However, it wraps up many thousand years old Iranian civilization development from inception to pre-islam. The first four chapters include Iranian mythology. and the last four chapters are about the begining of the Persian empire to the end around 6th century A.D. The writer is not a historian. He is trying to put together a book about the Iranian history which he felt missing in the market. The stories are short from each kingdom and pro-iranian. He put them in a chronological order. there is many editorial mistakes in this book. I recommend it to the Iranians who must be reminded of their very important history which they are very proud of.
Rating:
Summary: It taught me much about Iranian civilization
Review: This is realy my first book I am reading on Iran and the great Persian history. It gave me a great insight of the pre-islamic Iran. I agree that the book is not well edited. However, it wraps up many thousand years old Iranian civilization development from inception to pre-islam. The first four chapters include Iranian mythology. and the last four chapters are about the begining of the Persian empire to the end around 6th century A.D. The writer is not a historian. He is trying to put together a book about the Iranian history which he felt missing in the market. The stories are short from each kingdom and pro-iranian. He put them in a chronological order. there is many editorial mistakes in this book. I recommend it to the Iranians who must be reminded of their very important history which they are very proud of.
<< 1 >>
| 
