The Fredericksburg Campaign : October 1862-January 1863 (Great Campaigns Series)

Rating:
Summary: Needs to be re-edited.
Review: With Christmas season soon approaching, thoughts of home and a warm cozy spot by the fire may have surpassed any thoughts of war. Longing perhaps for a slice of Mother's homemade pie or a brief letter from home describing the latest events, men, many cold, hungry, and miserable went about their duties awaiting orders from their commanders. This terrible conflict showed no sign of ending and with the onset of colder weather, men dug in around Fredericksburg and waited. Both armies watching for signs of advance, until that fateful moment when General Ambrose E. Burnside, the unluckiest commander of the Civil War, took charge and laid forth a plan to cross the Rappahannock.

This complex plan if followed accordingly, would surprise General Robert E. Lee's Army of Northern Virginia and bring a swift end to the escalating conflict. However, crossing the river in the midst of winter became a logistical nightmare and the delaying actions caused by the weather allowed Lee's troops to occupy strong positions overlooking the town such as Marye's Heights.

Union men were sent into battle as if lambs led to the slaughter. Lead flew through the air like hoards of locusts during a plague, mowing down men where they stood. Bodies piled up and the living took refuge behind walls of once living flesh. Thumps of bullets could be heard as they entered the bloody makeshift walls as those clinging to life on the "killing ground" cried out for help. Burnside sent wave after wave of men to their death and even tried to rally his commanders by claiming he would personally lead men to the fight and win the day! He was finally persuaded to call of the attack with many of his troops lying on the cold bloody earth for the night. The cries of the dying intermixed with the hoarse prayers of those passing from this earth.

As one begins reading this work you begin to realize that more editing was needed before publication. The opening chapter of the book does a pretty good job of detailing the aftermath of Antietam. It gives a good account of the 178th Pennsylvania and their slaughter at Shepherdstown, and how the Rebel forces pushed them back across the Potomac. However, the 178th was not there - it was the 118th Pennsylvania, better known as the Corn Regiment from Philadelphia. This is not to say that the entire book is filled with errors, the detail and research that went into battle statistics were in good order but to miss the proper labeling of the regiment so early in the work is somewhat disturbing. Thorough editing would have picked up that key fact; alas it was not done.

The author does a good job in bringing the details of battle to light and carries the reader through the book at a nice pace without dulling the facts or swamping the reader with too much military tactics. The maps are easy to follow and the sidebars on the commanders are informative. I found the book to be enjoyable, but would like to see the book re-edited and hopefully brought back out in amended form. As is, it's adequate for those interested in the Fredericksburg Campaign and will do fine as a secondary source to primary source material.

Rating:
Summary: Needs to be re-edited.
Review: With Christmas season soon approaching, thoughts of home and a warm cozy spot by the fire may have surpassed any thoughts of war. Longing perhaps for a slice of Mother's homemade pie or a brief letter from home describing the latest events, men, many cold, hungry, and miserable went about their duties awaiting orders from their commanders. This terrible conflict showed no sign of ending and with the onset of colder weather, men dug in around Fredericksburg and waited. Both armies watching for signs of advance, until that fateful moment when General Ambrose E. Burnside, the unluckiest commander of the Civil War, took charge and laid forth a plan to cross the Rappahannock.

This complex plan if followed accordingly, would surprise General Robert E. Lee's Army of Northern Virginia and bring a swift end to the escalating conflict. However, crossing the river in the midst of winter became a logistical nightmare and the delaying actions caused by the weather allowed Lee's troops to occupy strong positions overlooking the town such as Marye's Heights.

Union men were sent into battle as if lambs led to the slaughter. Lead flew through the air like hoards of locusts during a plague, mowing down men where they stood. Bodies piled up and the living took refuge behind walls of once living flesh. Thumps of bullets could be heard as they entered the bloody makeshift walls as those clinging to life on the "killing ground" cried out for help. Burnside sent wave after wave of men to their death and even tried to rally his commanders by claiming he would personally lead men to the fight and win the day! He was finally persuaded to call of the attack with many of his troops lying on the cold bloody earth for the night. The cries of the dying intermixed with the hoarse prayers of those passing from this earth.

As one begins reading this work you begin to realize that more editing was needed before publication. The opening chapter of the book does a pretty good job of detailing the aftermath of Antietam. It gives a good account of the 178th Pennsylvania and their slaughter at Shepherdstown, and how the Rebel forces pushed them back across the Potomac. However, the 178th was not there - it was the 118th Pennsylvania, better known as the Corn Regiment from Philadelphia. This is not to say that the entire book is filled with errors, the detail and research that went into battle statistics were in good order but to miss the proper labeling of the regiment so early in the work is somewhat disturbing. Thorough editing would have picked up that key fact; alas it was not done.

The author does a good job in bringing the details of battle to light and carries the reader through the book at a nice pace without dulling the facts or swamping the reader with too much military tactics. The maps are easy to follow and the sidebars on the commanders are informative. I found the book to be enjoyable, but would like to see the book re-edited and hopefully brought back out in amended form. As is, it's adequate for those interested in the Fredericksburg Campaign and will do fine as a secondary source to primary source material.