On the Night Plain: A Novel

Rating:
Summary: Nicely Crafted
Review: I sort of came to this novel randomly and with no expectations, but I was very pleasantly surprised by it. Most of the action takes place on a family sheep ranch in Great Plains west not long after World War II. The main character is Grant Person, one of six sons of the ranch -- where life can be harrowing, to say the least. Lennon has apparently done a good deal of research to get the details of that life right (at times reminding of Ondaatje), and he has fashioned an interesting and surprising plot, but I think the thing that made the book work was how convincingly drawn each of the characters is; in the end, it's a very quiet and interior novel, despite the extremeness of the setting and the frequent occurrence of life-or-death situations. The upshot is a nicely crafted and engaging story. I found the resolution slightly unsatisfying, and some earlier sections of the book, before the story picked up momentum, weren't as strong. But these are comparatively minor complaints.

Rating:
Summary: Just plain good
Review: J. R. Lennon has mastered the art of capturing the simplest gesture or word , putting it on paper and evoking complex emotions and situations. In this, his third novel, the author takes us to the 1940s in Montana, a sheep ranch where two brothers, Grant and Max, with a complicated history, cut fleece, paint, build resentment and love the same woman. The use of "the dead man" in Grant's dreams is eerily effective. There is no clear cut hero or villian, though you do get inside the head of Grant, who allows himself to be seen as the bad guy rather than let his parents, now long gone, take the heat for tragedies in the family. Looking forward to Lennon's newest.

Rating:
Summary: Road to Nowhere
Review: Lack of quote marks, ultra-emotionally-reserved protagonist, a woman he can't have, the self-destruction of a farm -- is this Lennon's homage to Cormac McCarthy? Perhaps. This is by and large a one-note book, and that's what kills it. The book flatlines from beginning to end, and the supporting cast is no help -- they're either annoying (Sophia) or pretentious (Max). And the ending is just lame lame lame. I didn't expect to read The Funnies again, but this was downright torturous, a slow, muddled book that goes nowhere.

Rating:
Summary: Road to Nowhere
Review: Lack of quote marks, ultra-emotionally-reserved protagonist, a woman he can't have, the self-destruction of a farm -- is this Lennon's homage to Cormac McCarthy? Perhaps. This is by and large a one-note book, and that's what kills it. The book flatlines from beginning to end, and the supporting cast is no help -- they're either annoying (Sophia) or pretentious (Max). And the ending is just lame lame lame. I didn't expect to read The Funnies again, but this was downright torturous, a slow, muddled book that goes nowhere.

Rating:
Summary: Lucid and Heartbreaking
Review: Since the war with Japan ended, Grant Person has given a great deal of thought about leaving his family's remote ranch on the northern Great Plains. Grant who sees the haunting eyes of his parents and his younger brother Max daily cannot ignore the guilt of another sibling dying while serving his country in Grant's place. Unable to cope with the ghost, Grant takes the train east.

After several years away, Grant returns home to find his mother dead, his father gone, and Max abandoning the dilapidated ranch to paint. Grant decides to try to make a go of the ranch using the money he earned over the last few years as a sailor. A year later, Max returns with his girlfriend Sophia. Not long afterward, Grant and Sophia begin to fall in love splitting the siblings even more than when the older brother walked out several years ago.

ON THE NIGHT PLAIN is a perspicacious look at life on the Great Plains just after World War II. The story line paints a bleak picture of loneliness through the key characters, the two forlorn Pearson brothers. Readers will feel the bitter cold and solitude while trekking along the ranch. Once again J Robert Lennon has taken a dramatic twist from his previous novels (see THE LIGHT OF FALLING STARS and THE FUNNIES) by offering something new and different, yet retains the engaging prose expected of him.

Harriet Klausner

Rating:
Summary: Astounding and unforgettable
Review: The beauty of this novel comes through a restraint of language and a kind of authorial compassion. So much of the story is hard and upsetting, and so many of the characters are tragically bound by duty and lack of possibility, yet Lennon treats every moment with care. He refuses decoration or literary fuss or self-conscious writing of any kind, but rather than making it spare or cold, this restraint reveals a deep light at the center of the book.

Rating:
Summary: Burdens shouldered, a life endured. . .
Review: The world created by the novel is one where people in one way or another are crushed by the circumstances of their lives. Set in the 1940s in some unnamed state on the Great Plains, it recounts the early adulthood of a man born on a sheep ranch. The life he inherits is one of loss, mischance, and isolation. One by one his brothers die or are killed, as are his parents, until he is the last one alive. Although he is the point-of-view character throughout (and the reader is likely to feel trapped at times in his consciousness), we learn almost nothing of how he survives, except that he escapes for a while to work on a fishing boat in the Atlantic, and seems to turn off whatever thoughts he might have, knowing that any of them could easily lead him to despair.

Guilt and regrets visit him in the form of nightmares, in which a drowned man he once saw on a beach in Atlantic City haunts him wordlessly and gruesomely. These dreams merge so seamlessly with the narrative, it is easy to see the main character's daily existence as an unending bad dream. Briefly he becomes involved with a waitress at a restaurant in town, and in her presence he has moments that touch the tenderness in him, but the role he shoulders is to labor on alone, attempting to salvage the run-down family ranch with the help of hired hands either resigned as he is to their lot in life or bitterly resentful. When his brother, an artist, returns to the ranch with a girl he has met, her presence in this isolated world of laboring men takes a not surprising emotional toll.

This is a novel not for every taste. There's a bleakness that will disappoint readers looking for a more romanticized version of the subject matter. There's an emotional flatness that will not suit those looking for drama or even melodrama. There's an absence of introspection and reflection in the protagonist for those looking for psychological depth. Yet the novel chooses a minimalist narrative style (reflected, I suppose, in the absence of punctuation for dialogue) that is appropriate to its story and is in its own way compelling.

There is a kind of romance even in the absence of it that pulls you forward, watching the way events unfold among characters whose lives have been greatly reduced by the demands of an unforgiving environment. Author Lennon also has a remarkable gift of stark metaphor for capturing nuances of attitude and emotional coloring in both his characters and his landscape. Finally the book reveals much about sheep ranching for readers of Western literature who've become familiar with the details of raising and working cattle. For the success of the novel's particular vision, I'm happy to recommend it.