Run Silent Run Deep

Rating:
Summary: Definitely a classic
Review: I decided to read this book because of the excellent reviews. Edward Beach has created a submarine thriller with an atmosphere, although there are some adventures (like the fire on the carrier "Enterprise" while being in dry dock, or the saving of downed US fliers) that could be erased without affecting the overall story. The characters are ably described, the writer produces some unforgettable pictures of the periscope view and the crucial duel of Captain Richardson with the Japanese destroyer "Akikaze" (or "Bungo Pete") comes to crown the drama. Although the reader is led to suspect that such a duel will take place inevidently, I found it to be an anti-climax and "Bungo Pete" is destroyed rather easily (albeit Beach gives a few interesting tips on submarine tactics). I finished the book in 3 days and I consider it as one of the best in World War II military literature.

Rating:
Summary: Very atmospheric
Review: Run Silent, Run Deep is an exciting book based on the real life exploits of auther Edward L. Beach. Starting with training at sub school, this book lets us see through the eyes of submarine Captain Richardson as he trains his crew and takes them to war with the Japanese.

The submarine warefare sections are excellently written and extremely atmospheric, even in the training sections. Each time the story hit another naval combat section, I found myself unconciously reading quicker and quicker just through the excitement of it all.

The only criticism I could level at the book was that is was a little bit anti-climactic. As the story progresses, there are numerous references to the great Japanese sub-sinker called Bungo Pete. Predictably, the climax of the story is when Richardson himself is sent out to duel with Bungo Pete for one last cat and mouse duel. However, the duel is a little disappointing compared to some of the other naval encounters witnissed in the book, leaving the end a little unfulfilling.

Overall, an excellent book which I heartily recommend for anyone who wants to read a quick paced, action novel about submarine warfare.