Rating: 
Summary: An underrated gem for the Saylor enthusiast.
Review: A worthy contribution to the historical mystery genre (if such a classification exists), "The House of the Vestals" exhibits both the detective skills of Gordianus the Finder and the remarkable writing ability of his creator to telling effect.As Saylor himself points out in the foreword, some of his readers may have found themselves wondering what happened to the Roman sleuth between the years 80 BC (the setting of his first novel, "Roman Blood") and 72 BC (the year of the Spartacan slave revolt, as described in the sequel "Arms of Nemesis"). "The House of the Vestals" provides the answer, filling in the eight-year gap with nine intriguing short cases that test Gordianus' wits and leave the reader yearning for more. Four of the stories are based, in varying degrees, on real events (in accordance with Saylor's acknowledged writing style) while the rest dwell on aspects of Roman life that have come down from us through the ancient sources. "The House of the Vestals" -- the closing story from which the entire anthology derives its name -- is by far the most faithful to history, inspired by the allegations of unchastity levelled against two Vestal Virgins and their alleged paramours by the demagogue Publius Clodius in 73 BC. Some of the characters in this and the stories preceding it have featured in Saylor's other novels, ensuring that this "flashback" addition to an otherwise chronologically released series maintains full relevance all throughout Roma Sub Rosa and throwing in a bit of irony as to the eventual fate of recurrent figures. True enough, the stories included in the anthology are far too short for those (myself included) who may have gotten used to long-winded plots and vast settings in Saylor's other works. Be that as it may, the life of Gordianus the Finder could never be complete without these little in-betweeners to fill the time between more significant events. Moreover, "The House of the Vestals" offers a wonderful solution for people beset with a shortage of leisure time: read a story whenever you feel like it. (After all, for people like me, it takes a Herculean effort to pull away from a novel when things begin to turn exciting.)
Rating:
Summary: Delight yourself while accompanying Gordianus
Review: Fans of Gordianus, the Finder will be happy to get a hold of this book right away. It includes nine short stories in chronological order to be read after "Roman Blood" (the first novel in the series). Saylor's writing is so rich, that not only will appeal to mystery and history lovers, but also to lovers of ancient tragedies. "Death wears a mask" shows Gordianus in a theatre where, all of a sudden, murder strikes; but we cannot but marvel at the piece of lyrical dialogue briefly offered to us here. Unusual roman customs delight us in both "King Bee and Honey", a story of a passionate love affair that ends up in tragedy; and "The Lemures", where the mysteries of the Occult intertwine in the daily roman way of life. My favorite story in particular is the one that closes the book (and also titles it) "The House of the Vestals". The interesting part in this story is not only the plot in itself, but the way it shows a vivid picture of the temple consecrated to the Roman Goddess Vesta; with its gardens and fountains, and the lifestyle of the women who from a very early age were chosen to be offered to her as guardians of the eternal fire. Once more, reading Saylor teaches us about Rome and its character; while in the meantime, it teaches us about ourselves.
Rating:
Summary: more to the point than the novels
Review: For those who think - probably rightly so - that Mr. Saylor uses more pages than necessary for the story in his novels, this collection of short stories should be the choice. There is all I love about the Gordianus stories but more to the point, that is telling the story and not giving a lecture about ancient Rome. I really liked it.
Rating:
Summary: Wickedly Addictive Tales of Mystery in Ancient Rome
Review: I can't get enough of Steven Saylor's Gordianus the Finder, and this marvelous collection of short stories was like opening a box of Godiva chocolates - each one is delicious! I have read nearly all of the Roma Sub Rosa series featuring the wonderfully human, intelligent, and dedicated Gordianus, and come to think of him almost as an extended family member. For other Gordianus-aholics, this collection of stories nicely fills in the gaps left in the longer novels - finally we find out all about the night Catilina raped a Vestal...or did he? We hear Gordianus' sexy, sassy slave (now wife) tell tales of her native Alexandria, and we learn all about Lucius. But the best part of this collection is you need no previous experience with Gordianus to have a rollicking good time. As Gordianus winds through the streets of ancient Rome, exposing frauds, murderers, and thieves, you will be caught up in the spell Saylor's crisp writing always weaves. Warning: clear some shelf space. Once you're hooked on Gordianus, you'll want to read them all.
Rating:
Summary: Wickedly Addictive Tales of Mystery in Ancient Rome
Review: I can't get enough of Steven Saylor's Gordianus the Finder, and this marvelous collection of short stories was like opening a box of Godiva chocolates - each one is delicious! I have read nearly all of the Roma Sub Rosa series featuring the wonderfully human, intelligent, and dedicated Gordianus, and come to think of him almost as an extended family member. For other Gordianus-aholics, this collection of stories nicely fills in the gaps left in the longer novels - finally we find out all about the night Catilina raped a Vestal...or did he? We hear Gordianus' sexy, sassy slave (now wife) tell tales of her native Alexandria, and we learn all about Lucius. But the best part of this collection is you need no previous experience with Gordianus to have a rollicking good time. As Gordianus winds through the streets of ancient Rome, exposing frauds, murderers, and thieves, you will be caught up in the spell Saylor's crisp writing always weaves. Warning: clear some shelf space. Once you're hooked on Gordianus, you'll want to read them all.
Rating:
Summary: Even his short fiction in this series shines!
Review: I've loved Steven W. Saylor's work even before he published under this name and his Gordianus series is better by far. This is actually a collection of 9 short stories, all of which were previously published in mystery magazines. All of the stories are good solid character pieces with mysterious happenings and detective work that makes sense for the time period involved (90-73 BCE). Several of the stories are told as stories by one character to another though several are also the ongoing investigations of the finder himself. Historians may cringe a bit but frankly, in this ancient historian's opinion, Saylor's series is about the best I have ever read particularly his portrayal of slavery, a human institution often misunderstood and misrepresented by modern Americans.
Rating:
Summary: Even his short fiction in this series shines!
Review: I've loved Steven W. Saylor's work even before he published under this name and his Gordianus series is better by far. This is actually a collection of 9 short stories, all of which were previously published in mystery magazines. All of the stories are good solid character pieces with mysterious happenings and detective work that makes sense for the time period involved (90-73 BCE). Several of the stories are told as stories by one character to another though several are also the ongoing investigations of the finder himself. Historians may cringe a bit but frankly, in this ancient historian's opinion, Saylor's series is about the best I have ever read particularly his portrayal of slavery, a human institution often misunderstood and misrepresented by modern Americans.
Rating:
Summary: Wondeful stroll thru ancient times with a good friend.
Review: It is so easy to overlook the past, thinking of those who lived 2000 years ago as some crude, distant barbaric history that the human soul has now transcended. Not so. We haven't moved one whit in that time. But to revisit that era, we need a storyteller with a great gift for brining time and place and history back to life. Saylor is such a man. A scholar of ancient Rome, he has created Gordianus. And he has placed his hero in the most tumultuous of times. Each of the Gordianus novels is like meeting an old friend, a man of much dignity and insight into the human condition. Thank you, M. Saylor. Can we expect more
Rating: 
Summary: I will forget it quickly, but, neverthless.....
Review: My problem with Steven Saylor's "mysteries" is that they are not, in any meaningful sense, mysteries: as a sleuth, Gordianus is little better than mediocre, and we are not able to see him, in any way, developing anything approaching a trail of sustained thought allowing him to unravel a complex, dark intrigue; what matters in the Roma Subrosa novels is the sensitive reconstruction of the historical setting of Late Republican Rome, which, in the larger novels, always gives the impression of physical accuracy, as one almost feels that Saylor is describing living experience - not a lesser accomplishment when you think of it. Therefore the fact that, in this short-stories volume, one feels the absence of the usual broader historical canvases;neverthless, there's always a reasonable amount of savvy, racy, lush, almost physical prose that allows for sustained interest and makes it impossible to put down the book.
Rating: 
Summary: short whodunit stories from a writer of historical novels
Review: Roaming the Internet a couple of months ago I stumbled across "The House of the Vestals", a new title by Steven Saylor. Ordering the book via Amazon.com was a new experience and proved to be both simple and efficient. During my holidays in Italy - where else - I found the time to read this collection of short stories that provides us with some answers as to how Gordianus, the main character in Saylor's "Roma Sub Rosa" sequel, got his nickname "the Finder". "Roma Sub Rosa" is set in the period in Western history wherein ancient Rome was getting ready to change its government from a tormented republic to an long-lasting empire. Saylor has a broad knowledge of the era and has the ability to remodel hints in history, mostly concerning events on the byways of time, to breath-taking mysteries. Saylor's books are interesting in that they provide the reader with more than just a whodunit plot. They alo give a lot of insight in both the po! litics and everyday life in Rome around 50 B.C. Saylor evidently needs all the pages of a novel to elaborate both a gripping plot and the historical setting. He isn't able to do this within the confines of a short story. Sure, it's all there: the humor, sex and violence that the cover promises. But each plot of "House of the Vestals" is so thin that it left me with a feeling of "is that all there is?". Still, I am looking forward to his next novel.
|
