Rating: 
Summary: Ten Of The Most Important Seconds In History!
Review: "Stallion Gate" is a character novel, as opposed to the plot-driven suspense thrillers Martin Cruz Smith usually writes. It is also historical fiction, about one of the most extraordinary events precipitated by mankind, concluding with ten of the most important seconds in world history - the countdown for the test of the first nuclear weapon at Los Alamos, New Mexico.The story opens at Los Alamos in December, 1944. U.S. Army Sergeant Joe Pena, a Pueblo Indian who had seen action in the Pacific, was specifically requested by the Project's lead physicist, Robert "Oppy" Oppenheimer, to join the select and top secret group, in New Mexico, as his personal driver and body guard. Oppy had known Joe in his boyhood, when he left New York, for health reasons, to spend the summer in New Mexico. It was one of the happiest times of his life. Young Joe taught him to ride...and years later had still retained Oppy's trust. All the important historical characters are present at Los Alamos. Oppenheimer, his wife Kitty, scientist Klaus Fuchs, the Army general in charge of the project, Fermi, etc., are here. Anna Weiss, a fictional German Jewish mathematician, who had fled the Nazis, and been recruited by Oppy, is present. So is Joe's superior officer, Captain Augustino, an insane and bigoted intelligence officer with his own agenda. He believes Fuchs, Weiss and Openheimer are Soviet spies and has blackmailed Joe into informing on them...although Joe resists mightily and successfully, most of the time. There is little suspense in this novel. After all, we know that the atomic bomb test was successful, as well as we know of the other bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki by the Enola Gay. We know now who was a spy and who was unjustly accused. The storyline, is centered on Joe Pena, a complex, talented and very underestimated man. He disappointed his family, and had been disowned by his now deceased mother. Joe will never be a white man, nor a black man - although his ability to play jazz on the piano and understand the language of music like a native born to the country of chords and riffs, may have made his soul part Afro-American. He is really no longer a Native American either. He has seen and partaken of too much of the world to ever come home again. Pena fought like a hero on Baatan, and has fought heroically in the ring. Boxing was his sport and he was good. Throughout much of the book, he has no hopes for the future - no dreams. He observes everything and everyone, and comments occasionally with his sardonic humor. He thwarts Augustino's paranoid plots and assists a few renegade Indians, who try to work native magic to disrupt the explosion to come. He listens to Oppie who has lost weight and sleep with his anxiety over the Project. At one point Oppenheimer, while waiting for the rain to stop so he can meet the deadline for the test, says, "I am like the king of a rainy country, wealthy but helpless, young and ripe with death." Then, Joe, a lady's man - bedding officer's wives is forever getting him into trouble - falls in love with Anna Weiss. An opportunity to buy the Casa Manana, a nightclub in Santiago, NM, presents itself. Suddenly Pena dreams of owning the best jazz club outside of New York and Chicago...and the possibility of a future with Anna. The suspense does come Big Time, at the end of the novel, when all the forces at play, and the characters with their dillemas and choices, build toward their own personal climaxes - with an explosion that will impact the reader for some time to come. If you are looking for an Arkady Renko thriller, this is probably not the book for you. There are pages, especially at the beginning, when the story plods along at an excruciating pace. I hung in there because I was caught up in the lyrical beauty of Cruz Smith's writing. His description of Joe on the piano, what and how he plays, is classic. "If blue skies were going to explode on them, they were ready, so he made the melody,'...bluebirds singin' a song' even as he brought the 'Moon' down a chromatic descent, a chord at a time. The tunes merged and split again, accelerating until keyboard and crowd swung between flight and plunge and he cued the horns, who stood and hit Charlie Parker riffs that settled the argument by demanding 'How High The Moon?' as if it were the sun." Can't help it. I'm a sucker for good prose. At one point Joe says, "Which is why I love music. You hit a C and it's a C and that's all it is. Like speaking clearly for the first time. Like being intelligent. A Mozart or an Art Tatum sits at the piano and picks out the undeniable truth." Smith's descriptions of the desert's, (nature's), glory, is ironically juxtaposed with man's destruction and mutilation of the natural environment - so poignant and so gruesome. The radioactivity increasingly seeped into soil and water. Cows had to be checked with geiger counters before they could be slaughtered for consumption. At times, some of the animals' mutations were visible to the naked eye. Wild horses were machine-gunned from "B-29's." The author writes with a paintbrush. "The Hanging Garden got its name from the scarlet gillia, paintbrush and yarrow that had taken root and flourished in the turned soil of the hillside. The wildflowers were a brief, improbable splurge of colors - every shade of red, orange and madder - that turned and waved in any breeze crossing the dun drabness of the mesa." Lastly, Joe Pena is as strong and developed a character as Arkady Renko. I enjoyed every minute I read about him, and he will stay in my mind as a wonderful anti-hero of his time. J. Kraus
Rating: 
Summary: A Non-Fiction Novel (mostly novel)
Review: A great time in our scientific history is given an exciting portral by author Cruz Smith. Unfortunately, there is so much fiction inserted in the story that it alters it's the true flow and demeans the wonderful and courageous real-life characters of Oppenheimer, Groves, Fuchs (the spy), etc. In fact, the central character of Joe Pena is perposterous on it's face. A straight non-fiction telling of this fantastic time at Los Alamos would have been much more interesting.
Rating:
Summary: A Non-Fiction Novel (mostly novel)
Review: A great time in our scientific history is given an exciting portral by author Cruz Smith. Unfortunately, there is so much fiction inserted in the story that it alters it's the true flow and demeans the wonderful and courageous real-life characters of Oppenheimer, Groves, Fuchs (the spy), etc. In fact, the central character of Joe Pena is perposterous on it's face. A straight non-fiction telling of this fantastic time at Los Alamos would have been much more interesting.
Rating: 
Summary: Too Silly to Bother
Review: I had read Gorky Park, Red Square, Polar Star and Rose and thoroughly enjoyed them all. Therefore, I quickly bought Stallion Gate -- boy what a mistake. The book was a struggle from beginning to end. Our hero, Joe Pena, is just not believable at all and the plot turns are simply idiotic. Stick with the four books I listed above and if you haven't had enough of Martin Cruz Smith, read them again.
Rating:
Summary: Very Poor
Review: I stopped reading halfway through the book. The story never caught my interest nor made much sense. I just gave up. What a waste of time.
Rating:
Summary: No Action
Review: I would stick with the Gorky Park series, which is really this author's strong suit. This book just did not get moving and after 250 pages I gave up. I just did not care what happened to either the characters or in the story as a whole.
Rating:
Summary: No Action
Review: I would stick with the Gorky Park series, which is really this author's strong suit. This book just did not get moving and after 250 pages I gave up. I just did not care what happened to either the characters or in the story as a whole.
Rating:
Summary: August 6, 1945
Review: In New Mexico is a place called Los Alamos. A place called White Sands. And, if you're approved, you can gain entry through Stallion Gate. A couple of hundred miles apart, but of a piece. You kow the ending. But real people were involved in the making, not just the dying. This is Martin Cruz Smith's interpretation. An army general, an expatriot German scientist, a spy and a Native American changed the world forever. They have personal stories - this is one of them. It's fiction, but I appreciate the telling of the agonies and doubts these people must have gone through. Read it and weep or read it and cheer. Just read it!
Rating: 
Summary: Not Smith's Best
Review: Many writers today find a successful formula and stick to it... over and over. The only thing the same from Martin Cruz Smith's works are their high level of excitement, interesting characters and plot development. Stallion Gate doesn't live up to Smith's past work. What he does best is gives the reader an insiders' view of a setting totally different than what the audience is used to. Whether it be Los Alamos during the development of Man's deadliest weapon in this novel, Cuba in Havana Bay, Japan in December 4th: A Novel, or the Soviet Union in Gorky Park, with his characters on the verge of an exciting adventure for the reader to be a part of.
I enjoy Smith's books. Even Stallion Gate which isn't one of Smith's best efforts, still had more entertainment value than some other writers' best! John Row
Rating:
Summary: Not Smith's Best
Review: Many writers today find a successful formula and stick to it... over and over. The only thing the same from Martin Cruz Smith's works are their high level of excitement, interesting characters and plot development. Stallion Gate doesn't live up to Smith's past work. What he does best is gives the reader an insiders' view of a setting totally different than what the audience is used to. Whether it be Los Alamos during the development of Man's deadliest weapon in this novel, Cuba in Havana Bay, Japan in December 4th: A Novel, or the Soviet Union in Gorky Park, with his characters on the verge of an exciting adventure for the reader to be a part of.
I enjoy Smith's books. Even Stallion Gate which isn't one of Smith's best efforts, still had more entertainment value than some other writers' best! John Row
|
