The Balloon Man

Rating:
Summary: An Okay Book
Review: All of Charlotte MacLeod's books are zany and frequently require the reader to leap in joyful, but strange directions. The characters are charming if rarely life-like and that is part of the attraction. If you haven't read the books in both major series, please do. We will have no more. Ms. MacLeod is tragically "retired from writing" as a result of Alzheimer's.

Rating:
Summary: The Last One
Review: All of Charlotte MacLeod's books are zany and frequently require the reader to leap in joyful, but strange directions. The characters are charming if rarely life-like and that is part of the attraction. If you haven't read the books in both major series, please do. We will have no more. Ms. MacLeod is tragically "retired from writing" as a result of Alzheimer's.

Rating:
Summary: An Okay Book
Review: I have read many Charlotte MacLeod books in the past however this one was my least favorite. It took you forever to get into it. I was already half way through the book before any thing happened. It was long and boring at times. In the end it was okay but not one of her best. If you like Charlotte MacLeod, I reccomend The Family Vault.

Rating:
Summary: I would have loved this book if not for one thing...
Review: I've read the entire series and I haven't missed Alexander. Until this book I had no idea that Max still wondered about how he compared to Sara's first husband. I don't understand why Ms. MacLeod felt it necessary to demean Alexander. It was particularly difficult to understand how Sara could have been so unfair about Alexander because she had to work so hard to overcome her strict upbringing in the earlier books. Had she forgotten that? Shouldn't that have given her some sympathy, some insight into Alexander's soul? Alexander's mother was a domineering, EVIL woman. She was undoubtedly crushing any sign of independence from the time he was a child. I can tell you from personal experience how difficult it is to assert yourself if you were abused as a child. It took years of therapy for me to realize that I wasn't worthless and undeserving of happiness -- and my father was a fluffy kitten compared to Alexander's mother. I think Ms. MacLeod needs to bone up on adults who were abused as children. Perhaps then she'll realize why I say that the end of THE BALLOON MAN was a slap in our faces. Otherwise, this was another good entry in a delightful series.

Rating:
Summary: I would have loved this book if not for one thing...
Review: I've read the entire series and I haven't missed Alexander. Until this book I had no idea that Max still wondered about how he compared to Sara's first husband. I don't understand why Ms. MacLeod felt it necessary to demean Alexander. It was particularly difficult to understand how Sara could have been so unfair about Alexander because she had to work so hard to overcome her strict upbringing in the earlier books. Had she forgotten that? Shouldn't that have given her some sympathy, some insight into Alexander's soul? Alexander's mother was a domineering, EVIL woman. She was undoubtedly crushing any sign of independence from the time he was a child. I can tell you from personal experience how difficult it is to assert yourself if you were abused as a child. It took years of therapy for me to realize that I wasn't worthless and undeserving of happiness -- and my father was a fluffy kitten compared to Alexander's mother. I think Ms. MacLeod needs to bone up on adults who were abused as children. Perhaps then she'll realize why I say that the end of THE BALLOON MAN was a slap in our faces. Otherwise, this was another good entry in a delightful series.

Rating:
Summary: Absurdity and Desperate Emotions Nicely Intermingled...
Review: Maceod has such a talent for zany details and irrelevant (therefore,quite realistic!) conversation that it's easy to ignore the emotional content of her mysteries. As a devoted series reader,I've always been grateful for the way the spotlight moves from Sarah & Max to others in their circle and then back again -- it keeps the series fresh, I think.

This time, the focus is on Sarah & Max (and Davy) with a vengeance! The joyous confusion of Max's nephew's wedding is a grand setting for the return of an old,sad problem (set with rubies) from Sarah's first marriage. After confusion piled on confusion ("Damn it," sputtered Max, "can't we stop conversing in questions?") causes us and the characters to wish for something decisive to happen...it does...they do -- whatever! And then things don't STOP happening...

MacLeod keeps the drama of real and painful emotions balanced with the melodrama of the ridiculous. The people and the plot are delicious, and although I didn't want to put it down, I wasn't afraid to go to sleep,either. Silly & scary is a great combination! The wrap-up is classic MacLeod: confection, compassion and confusion.

If you're new to this series I would recommend that you read "The Family Vault" and "The Palace Guard", at least, before you tackle any of the others. My own preference would be to line 'em all up and knock 'em back one after another (Uncle Jem must be rubbing off on me), but it isn't essential...and certainly most of Sarah & Max's relatives would never be that logical!

Rating:
Summary: Meet Old Aquaintances!
Review: Yes, we meet them all again, Sarah, Max, Davy - who is less wooden than in previous books, more alive, if not yet perfect, but then a child can't be the shrewd, hardheaded original, as MacLeod's grownups usually are - Well, to continue, Theonia and Brooks, Jem and Egbert... Anybody out there, who did not know them yet? Read the other books! Because my only point of criticism is, that this new sequel lacks the "outer world". The good ones (old aquaintances!) are good. And the bad ones don't feature as much as they used to.. I miss some uglies, like the yachtclub-crew from "The Bilbao Looking Glass" or some new convincing crazies like in "The Convivial Codfish". Does it only seem to me, that the darker side of the previous stories has faded some, because none of the now very closely woven group can be sacrificed? (Like in other books, where at least one Kelling or several other group-members die?). OK, I don't mind! From time to time I want to read books where husbands are wonderful, eternal honeymoon is the rule, creeps and crazies are either family or dealt with efficiently, - well, Charlotte MacLeod will get you hooked on that easily accessible wonderful world of her literature. And this book is one of the entrances to it!