Real Jews: Secular Versus Ultra-Orthodox: The Struggle for Jewish Identity in Israel

Rating:
Summary: appreciation from outside the Jewish Community
Review: An amazingly readable examination of a poignant delima. Efron is a wise and experienced scholar most thoroughly attuned to the 21st century in all it's complexities, from sexual violence to political inanity. He is savy beyond belief about the economics gone wrong, the subtle psychology of both the "Black" and the secular Israely, and the long, sweet, hopeful history that built up to this situation and then went terribly awry in the last few years

But most personably, he is , in this timely work, coming up against his ethnic heritage and the pain of looking at the future for his small daughter and son.

Efron lets us see inside the man, how his lineage forces his compassion, how his own life struggle to become an honorable man, speaks metaphorically of the struggle of his beloved nation to become an honorable state, with its own richly diverse "family characters."

I found this a fine read indeed, and can only wish that a revised edition has some maps and a glossary for us uninitiated in the language and geography of Israel.

Rating:
Summary: Real problem for Israel
Review: I can say that this problem of secularist against traditional Judaisms is almost life and death on the streets of Israel. It is such a huge problem that everyone is afraid to comfront it openly, so you have to give a big credit in the fact that this book exists in the first place.

Rating:
Summary: Did King David wage war on the Sabbath???
Review: Many find interesting the sharp divide in Israel between secular and orthodox. Yet what many don't realize is the current manifestation of Judaism and Jewish debate only mirrors what took place in the time of King David when Ancient Israel was a Jewish state. The leaders of ancient Israel and the Jewish people of ancient Israel were bitterly divided between those that were overly observant and those that were marginally observant. The Bible tells stories of these people and their debates. This book details the epic and naturally Jewish debate over religion and observance. Between the ultra orthodox, to the orthodox who reject statehood to the religious Jews, the messianic Jews, the Ashkenazi and Sephardic and even the radical secularists of Shinui, and the labour Zionists. Israel is an extraordinary country because of its vast diversity in opinion. Never has the world seen such a `stiff necked' people who posses so many diverse and amazing qualities of debate. There is no correlation in Jordan or Saudi of the diverse religious opinions one sees in Israel. This book does a good job of presenting the current religious debates one finds in the Jewish state. An interesting account.

Rating:
Summary: Finally - Real Insights Into Israel's Greatest Challenge
Review: The single greatest compliment that I can offer "Real Jews" is that that the book is truly provocative -- in the very best sense of the word. I can remember no read of recent memory on any subject after which I more wanted to engage the author in discussion and debate. It hit many nerves and offered innumerable insights. There are other compliments of course that are worth mentioning.

Real Jews is well-written in the extreme sense of the world. Somehow, Dr. Efron manages to pack an optimal combinations of wit, scholarship, decency, erudition and clarity into his prose, the seriousness of the subject notwithstanding. The first person anecdote is used extremely efficaciously, moving the narrative along nicely, without making the book about the author. Sections where there is no choice but to bring the foreign reader up to speed, (say on the "Who is a Jew" rulings or the "Deri saga") are for the most part still fresh. And the book is not too long, even though I'm sure that this meant that there were many a golden passage heartbreakingly left on the cutting room floor.

As an Israeli academic who writes non-fiction about modern Israel, I would say that this is one of the most important books to come out about our country in recent years. It is surely the most enjoyable and thought-provoking. Most of all, it sounds an incisive warning that anyone who cares about Israel needs to hear: the Third Jewish Commonwealth can no longer ignore the enormous rift between its secular and religious societies if it wishes to avoid the fate of those that preceded it.

Dr. Alon Tal

Rating:
Summary: Two Gentile Thumbs Up
Review: This book explores the divide between the Ultra-Orthodox religious Israelis and their secular counterparts in the young nation. The author leaves no stone unturned in the delivery and the average reader is given enough detail to feel like an expert on the subject by the end of the book.

I recommend this book especially to anyone with a monolithic impression of Israel, as most Westerners with an opinion seem to have. Israeli society is far more complex than most of the world realizes and there is a lot of (some might say self-induced) tension beneath the surface.

Israel occupies a prominent place in world opinion. It is largely hated by Europeans and other Western sophisticates, despite having a very liberal society. Conversely it is loved by many American Evangelicals and others, who believe that it to be a religious (Biblical) state, despite the open hatred and fear in Israel of its most religious members.

This book explains why that fear exists and why, for example, the ultra-religious do not serve in the army. The author take pains to remain neutral in the debate, while at the same time plunging directly into the fray and asking tough question of both sides.


Rating:
Summary: Fascinating
Review: This books sets out to answer the question 'why do secular Israelis fear/dislike ultra-orthodox Jews so very much?'. I thought I knew a fair amount about this issue, and wasn't all that interested in learning more, but the book really surprised me -- it made me laugh and think, and I found myself citing it to many others.

The story is extremely well-told and compelling. Efron makes it easy to empathise with every side by illustrating each issue with personal anecdotes from his own life between the seams, as a yarmulke-wearing Jew living in a secular neighbourhood of Tel Aviv, teaching in a religious Jewish University but with a profoundly critical and feminist world view.

Buy this book if you know only a little about the issue, but especially if you think you already know all the answers!

Rating:
Summary: Fascinating
Review: This books sets out to answer the question 'why do secular Israelis fear/dislike ultra-orthodox Jews so very much?'. I thought I knew a fair amount about this issue, and wasn't all that interested in learning more, but the book really surprised me -- it made me laugh and think, and I found myself citing it to many others.

The story is extremely well-told and compelling. Efron makes it easy to empathise with every side by illustrating each issue with personal anecdotes from his own life between the seams, as a yarmulke-wearing Jew living in a secular neighbourhood of Tel Aviv, teaching in a religious Jewish University but with a profoundly critical and feminist world view.

Buy this book if you know only a little about the issue, but especially if you think you already know all the answers!

Rating:
Summary: Fascinating, unnerving, heartbreaking and moving
Review: This is an astonishing book. Reading it is something like watching a train wreck in slow motion: frightful but at the same time so compelling that you cannot turn away. Efron manages to describe the fears and antagonisms between secular and religous Jews with great sympathy for both sides. He writes with such elegance that the book is a joy to read, even if it is ultimately upsetting. If you read one book about Israel, or about Jews for that matter, this should be it.

Rating:
Summary: "Real Jews" is a real eye-opener
Review: This is an excellent and very balanced book which demonstrates that much of the dislike and fear of the Haredim ("Ultra-Orthodox")is a result of ignorance and a certain degree of bigotry on the part of secular Israelis. Efron reports on both sides of many issues which divide the 2 communities and shows how misunderstandings arise on both sides, how differences stem from differing world views and how, in some cases such as the army draft, one can use the statistics to prove both sides of the argument, for and against the status quo. I found the book informative, readable, honest and (as far as I can judge) unbiased. We see both sides "warts and all" and I came away with sympathy for some views on either side and the profound hope that, in the not-too-distant future, talk of secular and religious "sides" in Israel will disappear in a new mutual understanding and respect.

Rating:
Summary: A MASTERPIECE OF HONESTY, CLARITY AND VISION
Review: What a thrilling cliffhanger! No, no. REAL JEWS is not a novel; it's a real picture of human nature that serves as the engine driving people to act in their own "best" interests. Efron has delved into the mind of the Chiloni, into his psyche and unearthed not only how he sees the Charedi, but also shines the light on why he sees him that way. When I finished reading I was left with the feeling that, the Chiloni, in Kafkaesque fashion, is trapped in his own historical web and is almost compelled to see the Charedi as a parasitic, greedy, self-righteous primitive buffoon. He sees him as the "Tartuffe, Shylock, Falstaff, and Ruth" of society. He does so, in Dr. Efron's view, because the Charedi now has become the "other" antagonist (replacing the traditional anti-Semite) against whom the modern Zionist Jew reacts in his attempt to find his place in the world.

The artistry of the writer develops the picture to the ultimate that it carries the reader with that argument as if it were the last word. But alas! Like a magician, he flips over the coin and uncovers the weaknesses imbedded therein. He demonstrates that what the Secular Jew accuses the Ultra-Orthodox Jew of doing is the blemish that stains the accuser himself, the Chiloni. Noah Efron demonstrates that there exists a different set of values and rationale that motivates the Charedi Jew, and that the fear the secular Jew experiences toward the ultra-Orthodox is based more on irrationality and anticipation, and his failure to accept that the ultra-Orthodox act in the same self-interest as much as the secular Jew does.

In this turn again he delves into the mind of the Charedi Jew and unearths not only how he acts and how he sees the secular Jew, but also why he sees him that way.

It's a tearful commentary to read the last paragraph of the author's book.........."My grandparents did not live to see the self-assurance of secular Israel disintegrate. They did not live to be hated by people whom they loved so deeply, and for this I am relieved. Even in these very troubled times, I sometimes think that this relief saddens me most of all."

The unique quality I find in this work, REAL JEWS, is not merely the purposeful concealment of the author's viewpoint, but the clarity of the presentation of all sides of the argument. It is left to the reader to weigh them and to evaluate their merits. Noah Efron enhances his integrity in this effort as an "honest broker".

This achievement is in line with Jewish juridical procedure. It is axiomatic in Halacha, that if one cannot see all sides of an argument he does not see a complete picture of the event. It is for this reason the Talmud states in Sanhedrin 17a that in a capital case if all 23 judges vote guilty, the accused is not executed. This is based on a premise that if no one can present an opposing argument in defense of the accused, then there is a blinding, incomplete vision of the event, and society may not take a life without a clear decision.

Efron placed all sides on the table for all to see.

It's a great work!