<< 1 >>
Rating: 
Summary: Unsatisfying Collection of Essays on Interesting Theme
Review: "Ecosystem peoples," as used by Ray Dasmann, contrast with the more modern, mobile peoples that we have largely become. Gary Paul Nabhan usefully points out that ecosystem peoples are a positive feature of the ecosystem that they occupy. Their cultural practices, their stories, and their lifestyles promote the preservation of native habitats and species diversity. Unfortunately, this is the high-water mark of Nabhan's book. His stories are largely tired and lifeless. The essays are repetitive and, as a whole, lack any driving dynamic. The characters are out of focus and not memorable. If the book delivered only half of what the theme promised, it would be a great read. As it is, it is not.
Rating: 
Summary: Hauntingly beautiful without the least bit of romanticism
Review: Gary Nabhan's book has images in it that are complex and, judging by some of the reader's reviews, too fine-grained for some people's tastes. Like all great written works, Gary has taken the time not to oversimplify or over-generalize, but the resulting ambiguities and lack of forcing these essays into a pre-ordained thread has left me with images that will stick with me for a long time. They, like the ecosystems and cultures that he describes, point to a complexity which reveals itself slowly and over time--lifetimes, in some cases. It is this complexity that he celebrates and mourns the loss of as the cultures and languages that have evolved close to the land become increasingly diluted and discarded in the rush of assimilation that has overtaken so many cultures,languages and landscapes. His case for breathing life back into our landscapes THROUGH our culture and language is compelling, and a challenge to us all, wherever we live.
Rating:
Summary: Hauntingly beautiful without the least bit of romanticism
Review: Gary Nabhan's book has images in it that are complex and, judging by some of the reader's reviews, too fine-grained for some people's tastes. Like all great written works, Gary has taken the time not to oversimplify or over-generalize, but the resulting ambiguities and lack of forcing these essays into a pre-ordained thread has left me with images that will stick with me for a long time. They, like the ecosystems and cultures that he describes, point to a complexity which reveals itself slowly and over time--lifetimes, in some cases. It is this complexity that he celebrates and mourns the loss of as the cultures and languages that have evolved close to the land become increasingly diluted and discarded in the rush of assimilation that has overtaken so many cultures,languages and landscapes. His case for breathing life back into our landscapes THROUGH our culture and language is compelling, and a challenge to us all, wherever we live.
Rating:
Summary: We all need to see culture this way
Review: So few nature writers (Barry Lopez being one notable exception) are concerned with dissolving the artificial wall between humanity and nature. Nabhan takes this objective one step further by showing that biodiversity actually depends on the survival of human communities. In specific, human communities that have adapted to and depended upon natural systems for their own survival. For those who are interested in conservation, environmental science, human cultures, Native American societies, ethnobotany, archaeology, and anthropology, this book is a must-read.
Rating: 
Summary: Endangered interactions between humans and the natural world
Review: What is the proper term for someone like Gary Nabhan? Ethnoecologist? I found this to be a well written, thoroughly enjoyable book. I don't usually make it all the way to the end of a book of essays, but I read every one of these. I found Nabhan a pleasant traveling companion as I tagged along with him through the Sonoran Desert of Arizona and northern Mexico, sleuthing out the tatters and remants of native peoples' relationships with the habitats in which their cultures evolved. Nabhan is largely concerned with what Dan Janzen has called "the most insidious kind of extinction -- the extinction of interactions." Through visits with fascinating people in fascinating places, he explores what have now become highly endangered interactions between rare desert plants and their even rarer insect or mammal pollinators, between wild plants and their domesticators, between competitors for scarce natural resources (be they human or hummingbird), and between story tellers and their children and grandchildren. This is a book that will make you want to get to the roots of your relationship with the natural world by talking to your parents and grandparents about their own childhood experiences in nature. Whether your interests run primarily to botany, to zoology, or to anthropology, you will find much in these essays to please, sadden, and stimulate you.
Rating: 
Summary: Interesting ideas but too loosely written
Review: While I found his concepts very interesting and many of his stories beautiful in and of thesmelves, Nabhan fails to bring his book into a cohesive argument. He vaguely alludes to his concepts of the importance of biodiversity to cultures, and how a diversity of cultures promotes biodiversity, I felt as if I were drowning in nostalgia as he told this and that tale without making their significance clear and... significant. There were interesting thoughts and stories, but as an entire book, it disappointed me.
<< 1 >>
|
