Rating: 
Summary: Dazzling!
Review: "Crouching Tiger" is a blessing, a film that singlehandedly elevates the guilty pleasure of chop-sockey flicks to high art. Chow Yun-Fat and Michelle Yeoh are perfectly cast as lovers who are united by their past yet forbidden to act on that love by their code of honor. These talented actors say all there is to say with meaningful glances, conveying their mixed emotions of desire and regret. (The dialogue is also surprisingly good for a "kung fu flick," but is much more effective in Chinese with Engish sub-titles rather than dubbed in English.) Still, this movie is first and foremost a martial arts film -- albeit one with a heck of a love story. Two fight scenes in particular - an early one at night in a courtyard and a later scene in a sparring room - steal the entire movie. World-class athleticism combined with astounding choreography and a heart-pounding soundtrack -- sheer bliss! "Crouching Tiger" gives us heroes to cheer, villains to hiss, and colorful sidekicks to make us smile. Put this all together with stunning camerawork and a heart-breaking climax, and you've got yourself one heck of a picture! The only criticism of the DVD is the relative paltry offering of extras. But I'd rather have a great film with few extras than a mediocre film with a ton of goodies on the DVD.
Rating:
Summary: Mesmeric martial arts epic
Review: "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" is, without any equivocation, a dazzling martial arts picture which has somewhat revived a moribund genre. Kung fu films have, in general, undergone some considerable decline in recent years, with the exception of Hong Kong superstar Jet Li attempting to breath life into the stagnating line of formula-plotted bone-breaking fests. Credit must also go to Ang Lee for electing to do add a slightly innovative and unconventional touch to the genre. The cheesy dubbed dialogue (which translates poorly and hilariously) is jettisoned in favour of the original Chinese language subtitled into English, thus preserving the film's main saving grace, its culture. While mainstream kung fu afficionoados have grown weary of production-line plotlines generally involving the hero's lost mother/brother/pet goldfish, "Crouching Tiger..." eschews all of these stereotypes and sets about creating a truly authentic atmosphere. Lee's directorial style, incorporating balletic action sequences, high-octane martial arts feats is a marvel, and every minute detail is captured with a lovingness that most directors simply lack. The fight sequences are stunningly choreographed and the "flying" episodes appear intriguing. While Chow Yun Fat and Zhang Ziyi's treetop battle has been, in my opinion, much overrated, an even more absorbing martial arts encounter was that between Michelle Yeoh's Shu Lien and Ziyi's Jen. Both instances, both in the courtyard and the dojo are, quite unreservedly, the greatest martial arts displays ever captured on celluloid. Wo Ping's sequencing and choreography of the fight scenes is nonpareil, excelling even the work of the late, great Bruce Lee. The film is one of the best films ever made, devoted kung fu fans are strongly recommended to see it. Production standards (e.g. art direction, set design, costumes and cinematography) are all of the higest order.
Rating:
Summary: The Academy cheered, the martial arts film purists HOWLED
Review: "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" may be the most galvanizing film in the history of martial arts cinema. It is, claims the "old skool" core of fans that make up the base of support for the industry, a complete sell-out, relying on large-scale production values and special effects rather than legitimate fighting skills of the actors (with the notable exception of veteran martial arts female lead Michelle Yeoh) in order to sell itself; it is an act of sound and fury , signifying nothing.
To the vast bulk of the filmgoing public who wouldn't know "Drunken Master" from "The Master Of The Flying Guillotine" from "The Five Masters Of Death" from "The Five Deadly Venoms", that criticism meant...well, nothing at all. What is obvious from the first scene of this movie is that the director of this movie has fashioned a labor of love that has resulted in one of the most beautifully filmed movies in the history of cinema, regardless of genre.
Martial arts film purists seem to revel within the primative nature of the films that temd to define that genre. Poor acting, shallow scripts, ABYSSMAL overdubs, hack-and-slash editing...these are not the hallmarks of classically revered movies. Yet they seem to do more to define martial arts cinema than any other characteristic save that of the action itself. Yet "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" does not want for action. The combat scenes (particularly those involving Michelle Yeoh; Ang Lee definitely knew his most talented fighter and exploited her abilities to the max) are extraordinary, special-effects laden or not. The TRIUMPH of this movie is that is sees fit to actually present a story that draws the viewer in, that allows the viewer to form an opinion about the characters in between fight scenes...as opposed to just wishing that we could "fast-forward" to the next combat sequence.
What we have is a film more suited to the Classical Age, the Greek Tragedy with better fight choreography. The levity and sense of comic relief that could be expected with a number of Hong Kong cinema classics (and basically every Jackie Chan film ever made) is lacking here, but it is not missed as it has no place. Themes such as honor, social expectations, unrequited love (from unexpected sources), revenge (this is a kung fu movie, after all)...portrayed in an unconventional environment in an unusual setting (for Western audiences) make this an intriguing movie that has the bonus of some drop-dead action sequences that most people lacking a background in Hong Kong cinema are going to find quite amazing.
The acting is quite impressive. You will want to watch the Mandarin soundtrack with subtitles for the full appreciation of the effect (particularly taking into effect that the Hong Kong/Canton-based actors do not speak it normally); Chow Yun-Fat is best known for his "gun fu" movies made with John Woo, but the depth of his performance in this movie led to his casting opposite Jodie Foster in a non-musical remake of "The King And I". Michelle Yeoh and Zhang Zhi-yi (was she REALLY only a teenager when this movie was made???) are amazing and wonderfully strong female roles that aren't typically seen in Hong Kong cinema (clearly a male-dominated genre). Some people have called this movie the best chick flick since "Thelma and Louise", but anyone who would classify either movie in such strictly gender-limiting terms displays an ignorance which must prove to be quite burdensome and suffocatingly limiting. This is a terrific movie, transcending both genre and gender. It is the martial arts movie for people who don't like martial arts movies. It took home Oscars that neither Bruce Lee nor Jackie Chan will ever see. It is, simply speaking, what going to the movies is supposed to be all about. If you haven't seen it yet, you're absolutely cheating yourself.
Rating:
Summary: spectacular love story is original and breathtaking
Review: "Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon" is a film unlike any foreign film I have ever seen. Before seeing it or reading any of the reviews, one could assume that it would be a typical kung fu movie with the poorly done voice overs and the bad story. It is not even in the least. This DVD features the original theatrical subtitle version as well as an extremely well done voice over version. The story is hands down one of the best of this year. It contains two love stories, martial arts choreographed from Yuen Wo Ping (For those of you who have seen "The Matrix" you know what I'm talking about), beautiful acting, and some of the best scenery that I have seen since the deserts in "Lawrence of Arabia". Two great warriors (Chow Yun Fat and Michelle Yeoh) begin their new challenge when the 400 year old sword "the Green Destiny" is stolen. Zhang Ziyi plays an aristocrat who has a far away love and a strong temper. The film appears like it has extremely expensive special effects but the total cost of the film was 15 mil. Now lets get to the DVD extras. This DVD features more extras than some of the "Special Edition" DVDs that only have a trailer and production notes. The film features commentary from director Ang Lee(The Ice Storm, Sense and Sensibility) and writer James Schamus, a Bravo making of special, a conversation with Michelle Yeoh, and the U.S. and International trailer(There are more but these are the best). Finally, some DVDs are exiting to get at first but after a few weeks get old. Let me tell you, this is not one of them. With a plethora of extras, great acting, awe inspiring fight sequences, and amazing directing, this is a must buy.
Rating:
Summary: A well done martial arts soap opera
Review: "Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon" is misunderstood by most, including those who love it and those who hate it. Crouching Tiger lovers believe that this is the quintessential martial arts movie or that it is a profound reflection of Chinese history, culture, and drama. While the fighting scenes in this movie, are thrilling and fun to watch, they are more acrobatic and fantastic than anything else. I think that's what Ang Lee intended, and I'll explain why in a moment. As to the cultural significance of this film, there really isn't one unless you are interested in obscure academic topics such as the sociological significance of Chinese martial arts soap operas. And there lies the key: this film is essentially a supped up martial arts soap opera. Martial Arts soap operas are wildly popular throughout Asia and on many American TV stations with Asian language programs. I've seen many of them on Chinese TV programs in the US and China, and my wife used to watch them every weekend in the Southeast Asian city where she grew up. Martial Arts soap operas often feature the same themes as Crouching Tiger, such as avenging the master's death, restoring a treasure to its rightful owner, rescuing a damsel in distress, unrequited love, etc. They also feature many of the same combat scenarios including fighters flying at each other through the air, roof top chases, sword duels, ambushes, miracle healing, and so forth. These films are neither meant to showcase true martial arts performances like some of Jet Li's earlier works, or countless Main Land Chinese Kung Fu movies, nor are they intended to bring Chinese history to life. Instead, they are genre-driven, formulaic, fun, and often absurd. Does this mean that Crouching Tiger is a bad movie-absolutely not! I think Ang Lee quite deliberately set out to make a high-end, jazzed up martial arts soap opera. The first time I saw this movie in San Francisco, the largely Chinese audience enthusiastically applauded after the first fight scene, as did my wife and I. We had all seen this sort of thing hundreds of times before but never on such a magnificent scale with so much realism, grandeur, and suspense. Ang Lee pushed the martial arts soap opera genre to the limit, and he did so superbly. As the months went by I usually heard one of two responses to this film. The majority of people liked it but often claimed that it was deep, profound and revealing to them-that it taught them something about Chinese culture. The film's detractors on the other hand found the fight scenes unbelievable and the plot too melodramatic. I think both sets of people failed to realize that all they were watching was a really well done martial arts soap opera.
Rating:
Summary: A masterpiece of culture.
Review: "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" brilliantly shows the Chinese culture dealing with the martial arts. The flying scenes during battle exemplify the belief that once a martial arts student has reached mastery, they gain extraordinary powers. This belief has been handed down through centuries of stories depicting the great martial artist of China. Also, the use of the straight sword by the protagonist is correct. According to ancient beliefs, the straight sword is the weapon for masters. However, this mastery not only deals with martial art skills, but also a mastery of moral character. This is shown in the film by Yun-Fat Chow who is a moral and upright citizen who demonstrates the proper way to live. This is the main reason why the Green Destiny must be returned to Chow. If you are looking for a wonderful film that shows part of a great Chinese tradition, look no further!
Rating:
Summary: A Different Kind of Fairy Tale
Review: "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" is best described as a mythic/fantasy film. Michelle Yeoh and Chow Yun-Fat portray Shaolin kung fu adepts who are both investigating why a princess disappears at night. A past relationship between Yun-Fat and Yeoh's characters is hinted at very broadly, and the chemistry between the two stars is sizzling. There are some beautifully choreographed fight scenes, and gorgeous special effects (take particular note of the battle in the trees). The DVD,like the film, is subtitled in English. If you're like me, you'll find that (eventually) you can follow the dialog pretty well with only an occasional glance at the written words. Well worth purchasing, because you'll want to see it more than once.
Rating:
Summary: A day dream
Review: "Crouching tiger, hidden dragon" is quite simply the most swooning cinematic event I have been given to experience. I was aware of the hype coming in but I was still not prepared for the sheer, irresistible beauty it bestowed the screen. This is a film you have to embrace and let yourself be swept by its magic. This is what films are all about: make you dream and marvel at the way the world is presented to you. And the world of "Crouching tiger..." is a most exhilirating one with characters defying earthbound conventions with enthralling movements that make the expression "poetry in motion" come to life. And never has poetry been so universally spell-binding. But for all its magical, superhuman possibilities, the film is deeply rooted in raw human emotions, so that the "flying" (more like long-stride jumping) becomes a beautiful metaphor for the inner desires of the characters yearning to break out of societal "gravity", to be free to love at will. "It's a state of mind" says Li Mu Bai. I like mine to be bended by dreams of this dazzling proportion. Go see "Crouching tiger..." on the big screen before it is too late!
Rating: 
Summary: A Surprise
Review: "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" is the kind of film I usually wouldn't bother to see since I'm not a fan of action blockbusters. However, everyone I know was trying to get me to see it; I thought I'd give it a try(Even though I normally don't go by hype, I still haven't seen "The Gladiator".) "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" is more than an action film but can still be enjoyed that way. It has special effects which aren't just amazing to excite the audience but very beautiful to look at. It has a good script and story line. It has a somewhat spiritual connection. It has many aspects that can work with the average film goer to people like me who go more for Arty films. I wouldn't say it was the best film of 2000 or anything but it is worth renting.
Rating:
Summary: Mesmeric martial arts epic
Review: "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" is, without any equivocation, a dazzling martial arts picture which has somewhat revived a moribund genre. Kung fu films have, in general, undergone some considerable decline in recent years, with the exception of Hong Kong superstar Jet Li attempting to breath life into the stagnating line of formula-plotted bone-breaking fests. Credit must also go to Ang Lee for electing to do add a slightly innovative and unconventional touch to the genre. The cheesy dubbed dialogue (which translates poorly and hilariously) is jettisoned in favour of the original Chinese language subtitled into English, thus preserving the film's main saving grace, its culture. While mainstream kung fu afficionoados have grown weary of production-line plotlines generally involving the hero's lost mother/brother/pet goldfish, "Crouching Tiger..." eschews all of these stereotypes and sets about creating a truly authentic atmosphere. Lee's directorial style, incorporating balletic action sequences, high-octane martial arts feats is a marvel, and every minute detail is captured with a lovingness that most directors simply lack. The fight sequences are stunningly choreographed and the "flying" episodes appear intriguing. While Chow Yun Fat and Zhang Ziyi's treetop battle has been, in my opinion, much overrated, an even more absorbing martial arts encounter was that between Michelle Yeoh's Shu Lien and Ziyi's Jen. Both instances, both in the courtyard and the dojo are, quite unreservedly, the greatest martial arts displays ever captured on celluloid. Wo Ping's sequencing and choreography of the fight scenes is nonpareil, excelling even the work of the late, great Bruce Lee. The film is one of the best films ever made, devoted kung fu fans are strongly recommended to see it. Production standards (e.g. art direction, set design, costumes and cinematography) are all of the higest order.
|
