The Fall of Shane Mackade (Silhouette Special Edition, No 1022)

Rating:
Summary: I wish I could just order myself up a shane mackade to go!
Review: Since I spent most of the night re-reading this book, my opinion may be biased. I am tired. :) But I did enjoy this book. Out of the entire series, it may be my least favorite. But it's Nora, which means it is 10 times better than the anything else out there.

Rating:
Summary: Not my favorite, but still good
Review: Since I spent most of the night re-reading this book, my opinion may be biased. I am tired. :) But I did enjoy this book. Out of the entire series, it may be my least favorite. But it's Nora, which means it is 10 times better than the anything else out there.

Rating:
Summary: Simply Fabulous!
Review: The entire MacKade series was, after the "Born In..." and the "In Death...." series, the best collection of stories Nora Roberts (J.D. Robb) has ever written. Just be prepared to let chores go undone, families go unfed and bodies go unrested once you start reading because it simply becomes impossible to put these particular books down until the final page -- and even then you feel as though you want to immediately sit down and start re-reading them again.

Rating:
Summary: My favorite of the series
Review: The McKade series captivated me. Each couple matched so well. Shane and Rebecca didn't even see it coming, the attraction between them that is! This series remains one of my favorites.

Rating:
Summary: WOW! THIS BOOK SIZZLES!
Review: This is one of the best Nora Roberts books I have read. I must say Shane is one sexty hunk...I also like the personality of Rebecca, what a pair..This is a great romance!! Couldn't put it down!

Rating:
Summary: Disappointing Ending
Review: Unfortuately, when you are a writer of Nora Roberts' caliber, your books are compared to each other. Though this book is probably better than most Silhouettes, it falls short of Roberts' usual excellence. This book is the most lacking of the MacKade series. By this fourth book, the MacKade plot is so predictable: girl meet guy, because girl and guy are opposites they have sparks, girl and guy sleep together, problems arise, girl and guy sleep with each other in a "different" way (i.e. torrid first to tender second), girl and guy realize they're in love by how they made love, dramatic scene, happy ending. In this book, the ever-so-charming Shane introduced in the previous books is missing his charm and is rather boorish. Add to that a mediocre (and goofy) ghost subplot and a very disappointing epilogue that's doesn't even draw in of the previous characters! You simply do not have the high standards of the normally excellent work of Nora Roberts with this book.