Rating: 
Summary: whats up
Review: all the new saddle club books are on love or romance. what happend to horses? if you like romance, these are good if you like horses, try thoroughbred. I love the old saddle club books because they were about horses. the new ones are missing somthing.ACTUALLY THEY ARE MISSING EVERY THING.
Rating: 
Summary: A good read but slightly dramatic!
Review: I enjoyed reading this book and I do think that the author has managed to centre more of the action around Pine Hollow. However considering how much has happened to the girls it would be perhaps more realistic if more time had passed. I thought the end to the book was really sad. However it is true that even in real life you can go from happy and excited to miserable and depressed. Still I can't wait for the next one.
Rating:
Summary: Good, but could be better.
Review: I love the Pine Hollow series, but I was really disappointed with Carol's attitude. She didn't even ask Max if she could own Samson, she just assumed that Max thought she was perfect for the horse and give Samson to her. I think that in the future Pine Hollow books, another rider should come along who's better than Carol. She could use it to challenge herself more. It was really sad when Prancer died! It all happened so suddenly. I think it would've been better if she had died right after she would give birth. At least that way Lisa could keep a foal to remind her of Prancer. But in a way, Prancers death brought all three of the girls together; something that hadn't been done in a long time! I recommend this book to anyone who loves horses, but I suggest starting with the beggining of the series and work your way up. The books make a lot better sense that way.
Rating: 
Summary: I love saddle club and I think you should read this book!
Review: I love the Saddle Club, and I used to love Pine Hallow. If any of you have read the last one in the series, you can tell that she is ruining the whole series! It makes me really sad and really mad! I bought the book yesterday, and finished it today, becuase I could not put it down! I'm really upset about what happend, but I recommend that you read this book, really I did like it! It has many surprises, alot more bad then good, and I think that she is making too many bad things happen to them. I really reccomend this book to you
Rating:
Summary: Great book, but sad
Review: I love this series! They're a lot more realistic than most, but I do think maybe the characters(especially Lisa and Carole) deserve a break. I was shocked when Carole got grounded. Horses are her life! Like she hasn't punished herself enough. And i hope Ben stops being so distant.
Rating:
Summary: This was an excellent book!
Review: I loved this book to pieces.It was wonderful. I cried when poor Prancer died.Poor Baby!I felt SOOOOO sorry for Lisa.Now she'll never get a horse of her own.I think Col. Hanson needs to lighten up a little.He can punish Carole without banning her from Pine Hollow.Plus,she can't do her job.That must be bad for Max not only Carole.Oh well.I still LOVED THIS BOOK! It was SO good.I couldn't put it down.I'm getting anxious to read the next book.Ground Training.I read the synopis for that book and I can't wait to see what happens with Phil,Stevie,and A.J.P.S. Bonnie Bryant is a wonderful author!
Rating:
Summary: I loved it
Review: I really enjoy Pine Hollow books, especially this one. It's kind of like a soap opera. I think it's good for teens (especially girls, like me) but maybe some younger kids wouldn't like it. What I like about it is the reality of it. The characters are now experiencing real things, not like it Saddle Club books where there's almost always a happy ending. I loved the show and at the end of the book...oh, how sad! I practically cried. What I don't like it Carole's attitude. cheating on a test, then thinking Max would obviously give her Samson? She made a big mistake and I think her father is right for punishing her. And with AJ...this is pretty wierd that he's into drinking at 16! But I know it could happen so I'm not saying it's unreal. I just hope they catch him soon. And Lisa's mom and that guy? Ick! Poor Lisa, seeing her mom and that guy walk into the kitchen in the morning together! So overall, I rate this book 4 stars. It was pretty good. A little depressing for the characters, but I know the next books will clear up more of the storylines.
Rating:
Summary: Whata Great Book
Review: I thought this book was a great book. But the only thing i didnt like about it is how everything fell apart at the end. It wasnt a surprise that carol won at the show but i think she should have gotten to keep Samson. I think that the prancer thing should NOT have happened.Lisa deserves a break. This is one of the better books writen and it tells how not every storie is a fairy Tale.
Rating:
Summary: Okay this is getting a little ridiculous...
Review: Now I Understand That The World Is Not Perfect But I Also Know Its Not This Bad! Come On Now You Expect Us To Belive There Could Be A Car Crash, The Death of A Horse, The Serious Injury Of a Girl, The Decision Of Whether Or Not To Move To California, An Alcoholic Friend, A Newspaper That Exposes Personal Things Congressmans Family, The Cheating On a History Test, The Bad College Decision, The breakup of A Long TIme Couple, a Drunken Party, The Near Sale of Carole's Beloved Horse To A Person Who Dosen't Really Qualify As An Ideal Owner, The Sale Of Sampson, The Banning Of Carole from Pine Hollow, And The Death Of Prancer all in Nine Books Covering A Period Of About Five Months In The Supposedly Small Quiet Town Of Willow Creek? Personally I Find These Books Rather depressing And Kind Of Pointless. I Mean Whats The Use Of A Series where When One Problem Is Solved Another Immediatly Takes It Place? If You Loved The Saddle Club I Would Not Recommend This book. If Your The Kind Of Person Who Likes To Be Depressed by Millions On Never Ending Problems Then This Is Your Series. I Have No Clue Where Horses Are Going To Come Into this series While Carole Is Banned From Pine Hollow Since She was The Only One that spent much time around them anyway. P.S. The 1 Star Is For The Author Not The book.
Rating:
Summary: The best one yet!
Review: Oh this book was so sad! I swear i started crying when thefamous rider said for the second time he had made a good decision. Atfirst I thought he was the one who had owned him before, but it was so sad. I finally collected myself and finished reading and when I finally finished I sat for like an hour crying. It was so sad! But I think Carole is finally getting the respect she deserves. If only she can get Colonel Hanson to lighten up.... Only the next book will see! Can't wait to get it!
|
